But anyone who thinks climbers - even the best of todays models - are quieter and easier to use than a prepositioned ladder stand needs to have their head examined.
Let me clarify
"Ease" is a matter of total perspective & opinion.
"Quieter" may depend on the skills of the user.
Someone who hasn't been regularly using a climbing stand,
will have poor user skills, therefore may be biased against climbing stands.
Having a large number of ladder stands to inventory, service, and move around at least annually can be a time-consumptive task outside deer season. For me, it has become much "easier" to reduce all the time (and risks) of doing this.
I can typically relocate, both quieter & easier, a climbing stand than a ladder stand.
I can also do it more safely than how most users utilize ladder stands, seeming to have a false sense of security.
I do annually utilize ladder stands, they have their pros & cons.
I also utilize hang-ons, tripods, large permanent boxes, pop-up blinds, you name it. I use them all every season. But the climbers get the most of my time, as for me, they generally end up having the better balance of safety and hunting opportunity over the other types.
For certain,
once in place, ladder stands are very convenient for "easy" quick entry & exit.
But I've yet to see a metal one that didn't at times loudly "pop" from weight shifting, particularly on a great cold morning (usually while climbing). Loud metallic sound has, imo, ruined many opportunities, to the point I particularly avoid using metal ladder stands on cold, still mornings.
Since (
once in place) ladder stands are quicker (and easier) to hunt, they also tend to get hunted more often, actually often over-hunted. Over the years my conclusion has become that one of the best ways to ruin a good spot has been to place a ladder stand there, as they will most usually cause that spot to be over-hunted.
The only practical way to mitigate this may be by having a large number of ladder stands relative to the acreage, you know, like 100 ladder stands on a few hundred acres. Now we come back to the issue of annually "servicing" those 100 ladder stands. It's often been much "easier" for me to just use a climber. Safer & quieter, too
I suspect The BSK's climbing days were with the original "Baker" climber?
Those were extremely dangerous compared to anything we're doing today,
and nothing "easy" or quiet about them.