Can't say I can tell ANY difference whatsoever when I've planted Buck Forage and cheap oats side by side. Deer seemed to like both the same. There's probably some quality control and something a little bit better with the Buck Forage, but they're not worth twice the price for me.
I tried both and only plant Bob Oats now. One problem I had with Buck Forage was the husk seemed to be bigger on it and it would stop up constantly in my Moultrie spreader even on wide open.