Is this the same buck?

[DoubleRidge]

Bucks right main beams dont match.
One has brow tines one doesnt.
Very similar...but from only those two pics I vote different bucks.

 

[Ridgeline300]

Different deer. Top pic no brows and the right side beam is different. Bottom buck has a main beam that points more upwards.

 

[cbhunter]

I would wager they were born twins

 

[Snake]

I think they are different but definitely of the same blood line .

 

[Ski]

I would wager they were born twins

Now that is a solid plausibility.

 

[rem270]

Different deer, same genes.

 

[REM7]

Different bet their daddy is a frickin toad

 

[Popcorn]

Different Deer no doubt

 

[Tn Joe]

Same deer

 

[rifle02]

I think same deer and I also think it's possible that the brow tines have been broken off since the first picture was taken.

 

[BLOODTRAIL]

Same deer

 

[Setterman]

Different, right side is different at the end of the main beam

 

[JCDEERMAN]

Different deer. Daylight deer has brows, longer g2 and g3 on left antler, and right side has weird upward sweep. Night pic deer has no brows, short tines, and both sides are pretty symmetrical.

Same thing I saw. Different deer