5.56/.223 for deer opinion

[JN]

I shot a couple of doe with it one year using the federal fusion. All were good shots and farthest run was about 100 yards but was in a field and she ran to the edge of the woods and died there. I have had deer do the same thing with a .270 it is like they are conditioned to just run to the woods. I mainly used the .223 just to see if it would work and it did. My preferred rifle to use is a 30-30 in the woods where I prefer to be. If I do hunt the fields it is the .270.

On another note a few years ago I wanted to build an AR deer rifle with better knock down then the .223 and as I looked at ballistics of what calibers were available I came to the conclusion I was just wasting my money on a build that wasn't any better then my 30-30 or .270. So I bought a new scope for the 30-30 instead. Since then a few calibers have peaked my interest but not enough to drop the money on a build yet.

 

[megalomaniac]

Just fine if you do your part. That being said, not as much wiggle room for error, and often less blood trails than other calibers.

Will it do the job? Yes.
Are their other options that will do the job better? Yes.

 

[SES]

Where's Deer Assassin at? I have a .223 that I was going to use for hunting, but with the other heavier calibers at my disposal, I don't see the point. Heck, I'm still carrying my muzzleloader when I hit the woods. If it was the only rifle I had, I wouldn't hesitate. Since I have other rifles, I do hesitate. Tracking deer is no fun. Not finding a shot deer sucks out loud.

 

[Safari Hunt]

Bullets choice. FMJ is a no go for deer. 62 gr Barnes tsx is bad deer medicine. I have killed 5 deer with this load. Had 2 bang flops and the rest expired In sight. Bullet choice and shot placement gentlemen and the 223 is a viable deer round.FMJ i

FMJ is illegal in Tennessee.

 

[Rakkin6]

There's a difference in M855 and a hunting bullet.

We didn't carry the M855 green tips. We carried either AP or HP. I wasn't in the conventional Army. And still saw I'll effects on 130 pound targets.

 

[MusicCityCajun]

All the fuss over 223/5.56 too smal, Well I have seen bows fail but yet they are still a go to choice. Hmmmm

My broad head cuts a 2" hole through a deer. That's 50mm. So by that logic my bow is 10x larger than a 5.56.

 

[Mb423]

If you are running an AR platform you could just go with a 300 blackout barrel. I have taken a handful of deer with 300 blackout and great success.

 

[SES]

If you are running an AR platform you could just go with a 300 blackout barrel. I have taken a handful of deer with 300 blackout and great success.

Or a 50 Beowulf. Bang, flop.

 

[mike243]

I have had deer run when lung heart shot with 300wm, some 100y , I will use a 223 with good bullets with no fear of it not killing deer. you have to live with your choices and me with mine,

 

[Stalkhunter]

My broad head cuts a 2" hole through a deer. That's 50mm. So by that logic my bow is 10x larger than a 5.56.

Well i dropped a deer with no issues with AR 15. This disagreement could go on for ever.

I guess it can all be bad mouthed gun and bow.

Shot placement is everything no matter what you use.

 

[Stalkhunter]

I shot a deer last week 30/06 destroyed lungs and hit heart too. Deer ran 60 yards. I had a blood trail. When I shot deer with AR I had a blood trail. I used Fusion Ammo for deer in my AR.

 

[Rakkin6]

I knew I would stir up the hornets nest when I posted this.

 

[lung-buster]

I started my son with a 223 shooting a Barnes TSX bullet. It's one nasty little round and most were bang flop. The insides were just nasty with the damage it does to the vitals.

 

[TnKen]

I wouldn't and don't use it as my preferred caliber. I have done some doe control with the Barnes tsx and had good results. I was using Black Hills optimized 50 grain load and well placed shots drop them in their tracks.

 

[Pilchard]

It will kill. I have shot many with a 60gr partition in 22/250 and never had any trouble.

The question I ask myself is… If I were a deer and was going to be shot, what would I want to be shot with? For this reason, I normally pick something larger than a 22 caliber rifle.

 

[squackattack]

My kids have killed seven deer with one using ole core lokts. That being said all shots were within 70yards. Not my first choice but was what fit my kids at the time. I would use it again, but just not my cup of tea. I like flannel and lever guns.

 

[Gravey]

Never shot one with a .223 but have with the .243. My son started with the .243. Most times these days I carry my .270. 30-06 hasn't seen daylight in years except when opening the safe for something else. Like anything else it comes down to personal choice.

 

[spinal tap]

I've had success with the Barnes 55gr TSX. Shot placement matters.

 

[middleTNbowhunter]

I wouldn't personally use it when I have a .243 and other better calibers available at my disposal. However, I'd have no problem taking my wife or kids hunting with a .223 (with good ammo) if that's the rifle they like and shoot the best.

 

[Robtattoo]

This'll blow y'all's minds...... long read, but definitely worth it.

.223 for bear, deer, elk and moose.

DON'T HAVE TIME TO READ 176 PAGES? HERE'S THE CHEAT SHEET. “Bullets matter more than headstamps.” “Spent primers offer the supreme tutorial”. I’ve read it here and elsewhere online. It got my attention. I started digging and asking questions and listened. The 77gr TMK delivered by a .223...

www.rokslide.com