Shot my first velvet buck!

Tennessee Deer Sporting & Deer Hunting Community Forum

Help Support TNDeer | Tennessee Deer:

infoman jr.

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2003
Messages
9,085
City & State/Province
Louisville, KY
Obviously opportunities like these don't come around often. I had identified a couple of deer using a soybean field that were pretty solid deer. Both were likely 3.5, but a buck in velvet has long been a goal of mine. A couple months ago, I set a stand in a cedar tree overlooking said bean field from the West side. I love hunting from the cover of a well-trimmed cedar. You can practically do jumping jacks up there.



Anyway, the evening of opening day found me in the cedar. Early in the evening, the two bucks, a 10 and 11 point, stepped out about 150 yards south of me. Due to the obscure view provided by the cedar tree, I was unable to see exactly where they entered the field. They never came closer than 120 yards.



I was back in the cedar the following evening, and while the two bucks didn't show themselves, the majority of the deer were congregating in the same area the bucks visited the evening prior.

I knew I had to make a move on these deer before the velvet shed, the beans started to brown, and the bucks were off to different activities.

I was excited about this weekend. The past 2 seasons, I'd shot my buck on the second Saturday of the season. Just like the two seasons preceding this one, temps were dropping, and the moon was making an early evening appearance (both, I believe influence deer movement). Saturday evening, I chose to hunt a ladder stand on the East side of the field which would serve as an observation point. If something came close enough, great, but that wasn't necessarily the goal. I wanted to see exactly where the bucks were entering the field. I held onto my tree umbrella as a heck of a storm passed through.





Like clockwork, at 7:05, the two bucks entered the field, and I had a solid bead on the trail they used. Mission accomplished. The 10 point was actually making pretty decent pace toward my area of the field but hung up at about 80 yards. Now, the challenge would be to exit the field cleanly. I moved very slowly down the ladder and ducked down into the woods. I was unsure if I was detected, but I didn't hear any deer bound off.

At 2:00 yesterday, I approached the West end of the field where I'd seen the bucks enter and identified two options for trees to hang my lockon. One would offer a slight wind advantage at the expense of a longer shot. I chose to get tight to the trail. I knew this would be my last opportunity at a velvet deer for the season. I texted a buddy and said that this was going to go really good or really bad. Go big, or don't go big...right? With my pruners and Hooyman saw, I made fairly quick work of hanging my lockon on a small poplar. I had great cover in this little tree, and the thick undergrowth provided extra concealment as the deer entered the field.



The wind was the biggest gamble. My only hope was the the wind would take my scent over the deer who were approaching from the hollow behind me. This was an all-or-nothing kinda thing. The hunt started rather poorly. The first deer that approached came from behind me and was on track to come directly under my stand when he caught a whiff of where I'd stood and bounded off. I only caught a glimpse of antler as he turned and feared it was the 11 point. The fact that he was alone and didn't blow put my mind at ease. This was when I thought it just might happen. A doe and fawn (I'd seen these two several times) came in the field from downwind and ate for a bit.



Sometime later, I could hear another deer behind me. This one wasn't quite as impressed at my setup and proceeded to blow about 15 times. Great... My pity party was put on hold as 7:00 approached. I knew that if something was going to happen, it was going to happen soon. I made as little movement as possible and stayed standing. A few minutes after 7, I noticed movement downwind. It was a buck, and another, and another! It was the 10, 11, and a stud of a 2.5 year-old. I grabbed my range finder and ranged the 10 at 30 yards. The 11 (lefty, we called him) was estimated to be 25 yards. I came to full draw and aimed at the pocket of the 11 point's shoulder. I touched my release and watched the arrow impact and lodge into its offside shoulder. He spun around and left the field leaving the 10 point wondering what had just happened.



Once the 10 ran off, I immediately begin taking my stand down and waited for the other guy on the farm to get there so we could begin tracking. He commented that a deer had run across the farm road in front of him when he was driving close by (foreshadowing much?). A few yards into the woods, we found my arrow. It was soaked in blood and seemed to have great penetration. Spirits were high.



bddfcc22f63008bde51b7753a3617ff6.jpg


We had a difficult time following the blood trail with our flashlights, but the trail led (surprise!) to the exact spot he had seen the deer cross the road earlier. That was the last blood we found last night. I found one more drop of blood this morning. 4 guys and 2 dogs couldn't find this deer. My only guess is that I shot slightly too forward, missing the heart.

Anticlimactic, I know.

On one hand, I'm extremely gratified that I was able to move in on those deer and get well within bow range, however I'm extremely disappointed that I couldn't finish the job.

So long, Lefty.
 
Carlos Viagra":1sci745d said:
I wish things would have worked out better.

Get rid of those ridiculous broadheads please I'm begging you!!!!
It seems like I wouldn't get very good penetration or arrow flight if I didn't use a broadhead. :?:
 
Another horror story about a mechanical broadhead not doing the job. I'm sorry to hear that it cost you your first velvet buck.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
Great story but I'd prefer a different ending....keep your head up it'll come together on a Velvet buck eventually!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
He may still turn up, unfortunately he probably won;t be in velvet even if he did die.

Wish it had worked out for you. Great story, bad ending. Better luck next time.
 
Great post with an unfortunate ending. For what it is worth, I was pro mechanical broadheads for years when I was mainly shooting does and they would save my butt on shots that were a little back (liver/guts, etc), but would do me no justice when I hit forward, oftentimes limiting penetration and resulting in a wounded deer that I did not recover. Fast forward to five years ago when I started targeting decent/good bucks with my bow and I made the switch to Slick Trick. I won't look back. If I could shoot a bow as good as you (you obviously practice a lot, you have stellar bow hunting equipment, and have a passion for it) and I targeted mature bucks early season such as you, there is no way I would shoot anything other than a true flying fixed, such as the Slick Tricks. I do not mean for this to come across as negative in anyway, just food for thought for in the future. Best of luck for the remainder of the season, hopefully you will be presented with an additional opportunity in the near term. Great story as always, thanks for sharing.
 
Andy S.":1y31fmzq said:
Great post with an unfortunate ending. . . . . I made the switch to Slick Trick. I won't look back.

I've even sized "down" to the original smaller Slick Tricks, simply because they fly so well, offer even greater penetration, and still have 4-blades that makes a "bullet" hole. These 4-blade heads have the cutting edge of larger 3-blade heads, but tend to leave more a "hole" than simple a "cut".
 
Sorry for the unrecovered buck. That always stings especially on a great buck. We all know how that is. Remember that you learn so much more with failure than success. Try to move past it with the next success. It happens to everyone who hunts. Without failure, the success wouldn't be as sweet. You did 99 things out of 100 right! Next time you will get him.
 
Andy S.":o9sai17c said:
Great post with an unfortunate ending. For what it is worth, I was pro mechanical broadheads for years when I was mainly shooting does and they would save my butt on shots that were a little back (liver/guts, etc), but would do me no justice when I hit forward, oftentimes limiting penetration and resulting in a wounded deer that I did not recover. Fast forward to five years ago when I started targeting decent/good bucks with my bow and I made the switch to Slick Trick. I won't look back. If I could shoot a bow as good as you (you obviously practice a lot, you have stellar bow hunting equipment, and have a passion for it) and I targeted mature bucks early season such as you, there is no way I would shoot anything other than a true flying fixed, such as the Slick Tricks. I do not mean for this to come across as negative in anyway, just food for thought for in the future. Best of luck for the remainder of the season, hopefully you will be presented with an additional opportunity in the near term. Great story as always, thanks for sharing.
Well said and I agree 100%
 
Man that was a great read. Sorry it ended without you holding those horns!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Good story and a bad letdown... I know you feel a lot worse than any of us reading this. Better luck next time. Got to wonder what went wrong. I have a feeling that deer is dead now. but you may never know. At least there's a 10 and a stud 2.5 year old still running wild.
 
Great read and excellent pictures to illustrate the hunt. Wish you could have found him. Good luck the rest of the year!

I see plenty enough penetration (especially if you hit the opposite shoulder from entry) so I'm not sure why your thread got robbed with a mechanical broadHead debate. If you shot too far forward and missed vitals then it wasn't meant to be.

Hang in there and get another crack at a good one.
 
Don't give up on finding him. If he ends up dying, you have a good chance of finding him if you keep at it, especially late winter & early spring. No meat to eat, and maybe no pretty velvet, but you may still end up with a better ending. If you can make it back up there in the coming days, use your nose and watch the buzzards.
 
oh well man keep your head up.I know how your feeling though.im sure you will get another chance.Looks like a bunch of blood so a good hit i would think.But they are tough animals nothing surprises me any more.good luck let us know if you find him.
 
I appreciate everyone's comments.

TNReb":1is4vqkl said:
Sorry to hear that you didn't find him.

Also sorry to hear people bashing the choice of broadhead.
That's bound to happen in this kind of thread. I shoot mechanicals primarily because I know I can put them where I want. I switched to hypodermics to get the best penetration possible from an expandable.
 
infoman jr.":1w9lwbkd said:
I appreciate everyone's comments.

TNReb":1w9lwbkd said:
Sorry to hear that you didn't find him.

Also sorry to hear people bashing the choice of broadhead.
That's bound to happen in this kind of thread. I shoot mechanicals primarily because I know I can put them where I want. I switched to hypodermics to get the best penetration possible from an expandable.

I've shot fixed heads for the last several years but I'm switching to the Hypodermics this year also. I wanted to give them a shot.
 
I switched away from slick trick standards because even on perfect shots, I wasn't getting enough of a blood trail personally. I hate you lost it, but it does happen to all of us.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
Awesome story. Thanks for taking time to write and illustrate. Keep your head up. And I gotta say the same as others... no fan of the mechanicals. One bad experience for me, and that was it. Good luck on your next shot.
 
that is tough, and it sucks but it happens to most anyone who hunts and especially if you hunt and shoot a lot of animals.

My thoughts on arrow and broadhead flight, if your bow is "dialed in" and you are shooting correct complete arrow weight, you will have no issues shooting standard broadheads.

When I first started hunting, my broadheads flew great but wouldn't group with my field points so I tried mechanicals. Killed a few deer with them, all does except for one decent buck. I managed one morning to slip up on what may have been a 170" + buck, biggest buck I have ever personally had a chance to kill, I got within 10 feet. I was shooting an 80 lb pse, 550 grain arrow setup, when I got to where I was ready to draw, the buck turned and stared at me, no more than 10 feet and I am on the ground, after a minute or so he went back to hitting some bushes with his antlers. I shot him, slightly quartered away from me, saw the arrow go into his ribs and disappear, complete pass through as far as I know, never found the arrow, never found the buck. It was on a Sunday morning, took 3 vacation days from work and even though I had a good blood trail according to several friends who helped me look, and they swore I had shot a calf from the size of the tracks, we never found nothing. No more mechanicals for me ever again after that and from then on I have almost never shot a field point. I tune my bow and only shoot broadheads, out to 100 yards at times and I have no trouble shooting many different brands of broadheads and so long they are the same weight all have basically the same point of impact.

I hear over and over of how great the mechanicals are, and over and over I hear of a lost deer and the mechanicals are blamed and they swear them off. I don't know the reason, and I for sure don't blame the mechanicals becuase I have lost some deer with fixed blades, but I know for sure I am not worried about a fixed blade opening.

Another thought is I would not be tore up about it, people lose deer shot with guns every season, personally I believe just as many if not more than bowhunters. If you hunt with a gun or a bow long enough it will happen, well it won't if you don't kill any deer. I have made some bad shots on deer and either they died unbelievably quick or was just able to find them and I have also made great shots, have a couple on video so I know where they were shot, and not found them and have made what turned out to be perfect kill shots only to have the deer run to the "next county" and find it and wonder how in the heck it made it that far.
 
TNReb":30c0gffw said:
Also sorry to hear people bashing the choice of broadhead.
For the second time, I wasn't bashing, just offering up some friendly advice as previously stated. I wasn't there so I can't say this for sure, but I would wager a fair amount of money that the right fixed head entering that deer at the same spot would have blown through his other shoulder resulting in TWO holes, with the offside exit hole being lower, which typically leads to more blood, a better blood trail and a better chance of recovery. Two holes is always better than one. Again, not bashing, just a recommendation from 20+ years of shooting mechanical heads on 100+ deer and weighing the pros versus cons. Assuming both broadheads fly true, the ONLY shot a mechanical benefits you is a far back shot, that's it. If you can hit the vitals or a little forward (shoulder), like most of us can 95% of the time, a fixed broadhead will pay you more dividends over time compared to a mechanical, especially on bigger mature bucks that have an incredible will to live and get away when shot with a bow, regardless of who the shooter is.
 
Andy S.":35mktujl said:
TNReb":35mktujl said:
Also sorry to hear people bashing the choice of broadhead.
For the second time, I wasn't bashing, just offering up some friendly advice as previously stated.

I didn't call you out by name. Others called the heads "ridiculous", which seems like bashing to me. Don't take it personally, it wasn't intended that way.
 
TNReb":2plimudf said:
I didn't call you out by name. Others called the heads "ridiculous", which seems like bashing to me. Don't take it personally, it wasn't intended that way.
10-4. I have read most of the replies but I guess I missed the ridiculous comment. I agree, that is not appropriate in a situation such as this, no need to throw salt on the wound.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top