NYE Backstrap

Tennessee Deer Sporting & Deer Hunting Community Forum

Help Support TNDeer | Tennessee Deer:

you definitely know food poser no doubt.But i predict you are going to learn a bit about E. Coli in the near future
 
Negative, Ghostrider.

E. Coli is a strain of bacteria present in the fecal matter of mammals. It is mainly a concern for commercially raised critters, slaughtered en masse, who live knee-deep in turd-filled muck. The more meat is handled, processed, and ground, the higher likelihood of encountering the bad strains of E. Coli. Whole cuts of meat (especially properly handled) are the least susceptible to E. Coli bacteria. And of those circumstances where you might be introduced to it, it will likely be a result of cross-contamination from other E. Coli sources, rather than the interior of the meat you're consuming.

This has been a public service announcement of TAFKAP and the Ad Council.

tmyk.gif
 
TAFKAP said:
Negative, Ghostrider.

E. Coli is a strain of bacteria present in the fecal matter of mammals. It is mainly a concern for commercially raised critters, slaughtered en masse, who live knee-deep in turd-filled muck. The more meat is handled, processed, and ground, the higher likelihood of encountering the bad strains of E. Coli. Whole cuts of meat (especially properly handled) are the least susceptible to E. Coli bacteria. And of those circumstances where you might be introduced to it, it will likely be a result of cross-contamination from other E. Coli sources, rather than the interior of the meat you're consuming.

This has been a public service announcement of TAFKAP and the Ad Council.

tmyk.gif


sorry my friend but while many things in your posts are based in fact, new eviudence proves that free ranging deer of all species can contain e.coli bacteria. I have taugt on this subjects in both animal science and wildlife management classes. i can post about 100 more links if you like. ghostrider out.


http://www.sciencenews.org/view/generic ... i_bacteria
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
Poser said:
redblood said:
TAFKAP said:
Negative, Ghostrider.

E. Coli is a strain of bacteria present in the fecal matter of mammals. It is mainly a concern for commercially raised critters, slaughtered en masse, who live knee-deep in turd-filled muck. The more meat is handled, processed, and ground, the higher likelihood of encountering the bad strains of E. Coli. Whole cuts of meat (especially properly handled) are the least susceptible to E. Coli bacteria. And of those circumstances where you might be introduced to it, it will likely be a result of cross-contamination from other E. Coli sources, rather than the interior of the meat you're consuming.

This has been a public service announcement of TAFKAP and the Ad Council.

tmyk.gif


sorry my friend but while many things in your posts are based in fact, new eviudence proves that free ranging deer of all species can contain e.coli bacteria. I have taugt on this subjects in both animal science and wildlife management classes. i can post about 100 more links if you like. ghostrider out.


http://www.sciencenews.org/view/generic ... i_bacteria

Never gotten food poisoning from venison, never known of anyone who's gotten sick from venison. I've shared numerous medium rare meals with many folks and no one has ever gotten sick. This is properly handled, fresh venison. I would have no problem eating it raw.



proper handling is the key key, especially if the fecal matter is spilled into the abdomenable cavity. but to the fact is that any meat can be a source of e.coli. teh key is to reach 165 degrees temperature. most alarming is a new strain (or possible modification of existing strain) of e.coli that can resist temps up to 171 degrees. E.coli only fears one thing. Heat. Internal temps of 175 for 30 seconds, and there is virtually no risk of e.coli poisoning. The loin in the picture, wouildnt break 120 internal temp, i would wager
 
Poser said:
Ok, lets focus on this paragraph:

The deer had been shot through the abdomen in Vermont but evaded capture for 2 hours, allowing E. coli to escape the gut and invade the bloodstream, Dingman says. The carcass wasn't refrigerated or butchered for 2 days, during which time the outside temperature rose to 55�F, ample warmth for bacteria to survive, says Dingman. "This was a classic case of what not to do with deer," he says.

Under these circumstances, I would perhaps handle the meat differently, but the deer in the pic above was but gutted within 5 minutes of death on a cold day. The backstrap in the pic is one day old. -hardly a recipe for E. Coli, hardly a concern.



no doubt the deer in the article had been mishandled. But so have many deer at the processors. i know you handle your dee rproperly and quickly, but many readers on here may think that since you cook your deer to such a low level of internal heat, they can cook theirs as well, even though they pick their up at the processors.
 
Poser said:
redblood said:
TAFKAP said:
Negative, Ghostrider.

E. Coli is a strain of bacteria present in the fecal matter of mammals. It is mainly a concern for commercially raised critters, slaughtered en masse, who live knee-deep in turd-filled muck. The more meat is handled, processed, and ground, the higher likelihood of encountering the bad strains of E. Coli. Whole cuts of meat (especially properly handled) are the least susceptible to E. Coli bacteria. And of those circumstances where you might be introduced to it, it will likely be a result of cross-contamination from other E. Coli sources, rather than the interior of the meat you're consuming.

This has been a public service announcement of TAFKAP and the Ad Council.

tmyk.gif


sorry my friend but while many things in your posts are based in fact, new eviudence proves that free ranging deer of all species can contain e.coli bacteria. I have taugt on this subjects in both animal science and wildlife management classes. i can post about 100 more links if you like. ghostrider out.


http://www.sciencenews.org/view/generic ... i_bacteria

Never gotten food poisoning from venison, never known of anyone who's gotten sick from venison. I've shared numerous medium rare meals with many folks and no one has ever gotten sick. This is properly handled, fresh venison. I would have no problem eating it raw.

Yep. And I didn't say that it's not present in deer....quite the contrary. It is present in all mammals, but human sickness as a result of E. Coli can nearly always be faulted with the handling of the meat prior to cooking. Specifically, the process of grinding contaminated meat with other "healthy" meat. I doubt very many of those studies will show evidence of E. Coli deep within the muscle tissue, either.
 
redblood said:
no doubt the deer in the article had been mishandled. But so have many deer at the processors. i know you handle your dee rproperly and quickly, but many readers on here may think that since you cook your deer to such a low level of internal heat, they can cook theirs as well, even though they pick their up at the processors.

Even stil, I would be perfectly comfortable cooking a backstrap to medium rare, even if handled by a contaminated processor. The external surface of the meat contains the bacteria, not the interior of the muscle mass. All cooking methods will address surface bacteria of any whole cut of meat.
 
redblood said:
teh key is to reach 165 degrees temperature. most alarming is a new strain (or possible modification of existing strain) of e.coli that can resist temps up to 171 degrees. E.coli only fears one thing. Heat. Internal temps of 175 for 30 seconds, and there is virtually no risk of e.coli poisoning. The loin in the picture, wouildnt break 120 internal temp, i would wager

If I had to cook venison or beef to 165 or even God forbid 175 degrees I would just eat pork or chicken. No thanks. I will take the minimal chance and continue to eat rare meat and enjoy my food.
 
I'd eat shoe leather before I'd over cook a piece of backstrap like that. Besides...I drive the streets of Memphis on a daily basis. Last thing I'm gonna worry about is dying from under cooked venison. LoL.
 
BuckWild said:
I'd eat shoe leather before I'd over cook a piece of backstrap like that. Besides...I drive the streets of Memphis on a daily basis. Last thing I'm gonna worry about is dying from under cooked venison. LoL.

LOL right there with ya!

I'm all too familiar with South Memphis 5 days out of the week (if not more).

As the old Memphian saying goes...
"If a street's name is a state, it's prob'ly not safe."
 
BuckWild said:
I'd eat shoe leather before I'd over cook a piece of backstrap like that. Besides...I drive the streets of Memphis on a daily basis. Last thing I'm gonna worry about is dying from under cooked venison. LoL.

u got a point there
 
E. Coli lives in the intestines of most animals. The issue comes with cross contamination. If E.Coli were to somehow get on the loin, steak, or roast, then the searing of the surface would kill all contaminants. The only concern would be if the animal was gut shot and the E. Coli that is located in the intestines were to enter into the blood stream and then be distributed into the muscle. Typically, if E. Coli contamination was to happen, then it would only be located only on the muscle's surface.

Ground beef or venison: When ground the surface moves to the inside, outside, & everywhere. This is why all ground meat is recommended to be fully cooked.

I really like my steaks Rare/Med. Rare.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top