I let a "shooter" walk...

Tennessee Deer Sporting & Deer Hunting Community Forum

Help Support TNDeer | Tennessee Deer:

infoman jr.

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2003
Messages
9,085
City & State/Province
Louisville, KY
Deer season is in full swing up here in Kentucky. I've already done better than last year; I've laid eyes upon a buck with a sizable rack. I've been tracking these guys since June over 3 different cameras. I had originally decided that I would shoot this particular 12 point (he's probably a 10 now as not all of his kickers will be scoreable, but I still call him the 12). That was until new deer started to show up. An 8 point that will probably push 140" and a deer that will score...quite a bit more (I call him Club). I won't post a picture of the larger deer until I kill him or the season is over, but here he is last year.
PICT0039.jpg


Anyway, last week I was getting all these bucks on camera, and I was having this huge internal dilemma as to what to hold out for. I made the decision to go in opening afternoon, pull my camera and look at the recent activity. MRI as the Drurys would say. I would set my expectations accordingly. Club had been on camera before daylight that morning, and the big 8 had been there the day before. The 12 point had been there pretty much every evening during daylight. I then decided that as long as Club and the Big 8 are in the area, I will hold out for them.

The spot I'm hunting is a cedar tree in a thicket on the edge of a soy bean field. This is a secluded field surrounded by a 30 yard wide strip of woods in the middle of about 100 acres of soybeans. By middle, I mean I walk half a mile through standing beans to access the stand, so I only hunt it in the afternoons. Opening evening goes by and I see 5 does. I didn't hunt Sunday because of the rain. I went back out Monday at 11:30 and would stay til dark. About 7PM, I hear a noise in the beans and the 12 is 15 yards from me and closing. I watched that deer for 15 minutes within spitting distance. That was the biggest deer I'd had in bow range ever and bigger than any deer I've shot with any weapon. The biggest deer I've killed with a bow was a 4 point. It was a neat experience. I can't say I was happy to let him walk, but I couldn't stand the thought of those other two deer walking around for the next 5 months. Oh the joys of a 1-buck limit (but let's save that conversation for a different thread). Here's a picture I took with my camera through my binos:
DSC07478.jpg


Bowriter made an excellent point about the old saying, never pass on the first day what you would shoot on the last. That's a valid point worth considering. I usually subscribe to that belief, however I had the choice of shooting a pretty darn good deer or hunting for the deer of a lifetime. I chose to hunt. I may end up without a buck again this year, but I'll end up satisfied either way. I guess the 12 point isn't a shooter anymore, and if I kill one of these big deer, it'll be icing on the cake.

Here are the 12 and Big 8
PRMS0765.jpg
 
Really in your mind you already won whether you get the big one or not. The hunt is what makes the blood flow it is a great position to be able to see yourself mature in letting your patience for what you want. It will be interesting to see how much they test you and keep walking by.
 
Good choice IMO! Having that buck dead to rights inside 15 yards is as good as killing him IMO! YOU know you beat him, now on to a bigger challenge that will make you happier, thats what its all about!! Good luck with them!
 
Winchester said:
Good choice IMO! Having that buck dead to rights inside 15 yards is as good as killing him IMO! YOU know you beat him, now on to a bigger challenge that will make you happier, thats what its all about!! Good luck with them!

Well said and x2
 
I love and I mean love seeing nice deer/ all deer in the stand. But when I pass a decent buck. It ends up being more rewarding. Good luck bud. And that's a great great 8 point your going after
 
"Put me in coach! Put me in!"
Sounds like you're in the game to me. Have fun and enjoy. Buck tag soup eats alot better when you know you had one or more dead to rights and let them walk by the end of the season. Hopefully you'll get your shot. Good luck.
 
Winchester said:
Good choice IMO! Having that buck dead to rights inside 15 yards is as good as killing him IMO! YOU know you beat him, now on to a bigger challenge that will make you happier, thats what its all about!! Good luck with them!

I totally agree!
 
In my opinion, very good decision. Just think of what the "12" should look like next year! Buddy on our lease shot a 2.5 year old 10 point on our lease last year. He was about sick when he put his hands on it (me as well). He would have been a stud this year!
 
Well dang. I had my chance. The Big 8 and his friend were frolicking about just 15 yards from my tree stand yesterday morning, even sparring at one point. The deer with him is one he has run around with this summer. I call him the split brow 10. His rack has continued to impress me as it has developed. But where was I yesterday morning?? I was eating french toast in my living room. I guess I could've stalked in there shortly after daylight. You know what they say about hindsight... The weather is the exact same this morning as it was yesterday. I'd give anything to be in the stand right now!
PRMS02282.jpg


Thanks for the encouragement. You won't believe it when you see the really big one. He hasn't been on camera since Sept. 1 though.
 
Tonight was strike 2. I had him at 10 yards once more. I'm glad I decided not to shoot him. He lost his velvet starting on Thursday night, and he lost a ton of mass. It was neat to see him again. I got cocky after my last encounter with him and made some jerky movements trying to get my camera. He busted me and stomped probably 20 times. Luckily he didn't blow out of there. He just continued to feed. I got away with one big time. I wish he would teach his larger racked brethren his habits.
1291012.jpg
 

Latest posts

Back
Top