I'm not really a rifle person, but I love shotguns. I will never ever buy a used semi-auto from anyone..period. I narrow down what I like by past experiences with performance and overall look/reliability. If I have'nt owned it, I will give it the benefit of a doubt unless it is an absurdly cheap semi auto. I learned a long time ago, you get what you pay for, sure your 350.00 new semi auto may shoot flawlessly now, but whats it goin to do in 5+ years? Probably be a 350.00 single shot. jmo from my own experiences.
IMO benelli's will never be in my house, owned a lemon and the lousiest customer service on the planet. I've seen berettas fail in bad conditions, but I am open to new stuff that may be available that are different models. I watched a new franchi basically fall apart in a duck blind one day. The old "light as a feather" franchi's are awesome though. Never shot a winchester shotgun, so I'm open to them.
Basically a remington pump (wingmaster, special purpose, or express) have never failed me one time. And old humpback brownings are awesome. I will drool anytime I see an old "light 12" or a "light 20". I'm a sucker for small gauge shotguns also, 28's and 410's. I've sold about 15 guns in my life and with the exception of the benelli and one rifle, I wish I had all my shotguns back, from the Rem SP-10 to the Mossberg 410. Presently I'm looking a for browning o/u.
The way I see it, you've got one chance to impress me a shotgun so it better not be a POS because I will remember it and never buy anothequote]
I am just the opposite. I love fine rifles, shotguns are just a necessary tool. Having said that I have a beautiful browning belgium with amazing walnut and not a single scratch. Circa 1976