Jay, were the "push it till it seats" groups higher or lower than the "tamping" groups?
I'm interested in what the pressure was doing. Higher grouping should equal higher pressures. Compressing the powder should have increased the pressure, getting you higher velocities.
I agree with not tamping. You could deform the bullet, but the larger problem is getting the same compression shot to shot, which would decrease the accuracy potential of the load. Consistent powder loads are only half the battle. Maxing out accuracy requires that every step in cleaning, loading and shooting be as consistent as possible shot to shot.
I just starting shooting BH209, and did some experimenting. I found that the groups got smaller with:
-Tighter wads...I tried the TC yellow "superglide" wads, which didn't shoot as well as the black "magnum" wads (Shockwave). In my Omega, the black ones are harder to load, but the groups shrank by at least an inch. Over the years I have found that experimenting with different plastic sabot wads is much more effective (faster and cheaper) than fooling around with bullets and powder charges. It's hard to beat 100 grains of anything and a 250 grain bullet. But sometimes you have to try several different sabots to get good groups.
-Wiping the bore after each shot. Yeah, I could load without wiping with the Blackhorn. But the groups say wipe it out. I did a "wet patch, dry patch, dry patch" routine. The second dry patch was always almost perfectly white. I am partial to wiping anyway, because I want all shots to go to the same point of impact, which requires the same barrel condition each shot.
-I also found that BH powder granules are larger than Trip 7, which makes it trickier to get consistent powder charges. I've got a funnel that screws on to the top of those powder jugs and one of the clear plastic powder measures with the funnel top that swivels. I settled on a slow pour from the jug to the measure, overfill the measure just slightly, and close the funnel on top of the measure to "scrape off" the excess powder. You want to experiment, tap your measure on a table and see how much extra powder you can get into that measure...it's eyeopening.
The load I settled on with the BH209: 100gr BH, 250gr Shockwave bonded (blue tip), CCI 209 Magnum primers. This load averaged just over 1.5" at 100yds over 5 3-shot groups.