Yeah, this one threw me for a loop. After recovering him, I guessed 3 1/2 based on his body, but when I pulled his jaw I didn't know what to think.
He had three small holes in his antlers. What causes those? Also, what do you make of his right side? The tines aren't broken off, but the right side does have a 2-3" kicker that grew horizontal from the base toward the back of his head. I could find no visible injuries.