Anyone guess this deer's age?

[AlabamaSwamper]

I was thinking 2.5y/o.

Pic was taken in January or February.

Now this deer. Same time frame.

 

[buckhorn40]

2.5 JMO

 

[AlabamaSwamper]

I'm thinking the 2nd deer is 3.5-4.5.

Whatever the ages, we now have a 10pt that I believe is one of these deer. All horn characteristics are very, very similiar. THe 2nd deer's beams/browtines are almost identical to the 10pt this year.

Am I wrong?

Not that any of this is important. lol I'm just bored and curious to your opinions.

 

[AlabamaSwamper]

2nd deer again.

 

[AlabamaSwamper]

Deer #2 has 4" bases. I know because I have the left shed. lol

WOuld be very, very uncommon for a 2.5y/o buck on our place to have mass like this. In fact, be pretty uncommon for a 3.5y/o to have that kind of mass. The whole beam is pretty thick.

 

[KANATI McD]

2.5 in the 1st ptc the second one is PROBABLY 4.5
very nice deer!!!!!!!!

 

[Food Plot 101]

Ditto that DD.

 

[AlabamaSwamper]

I passed on the first deer one morning. I thought he was a 7pt and was to small either way. Once we got pics of him pretty regular at that location, I knew that had to be him. He is real small, even smaller than those pics show.

 

[ol 'rube]

2.5

 

[Tiny]

1- 1.5 but as mentioned need a better view.
2- 4.5 +