Video from the other day

Tennessee Deer Sporting & Deer Hunting Community Forum

Help Support TNDeer | Tennessee Deer:

Roost 1":33doj5uq said:
Nice video but I wouldn't call shooting one in strut a perfect shot. Just my opinion.
I told him to yell at the bird to get his head up but right then he shot... the breast only had 3 or 4 pellets, was not bad at all.
 
Roost 1":35pvutgm said:
Nice video but I wouldn't call shooting one in strut a perfect shot. Just my opinion.
My opinion as well. I lost a bird years ago because I shot him in strut. 42 yards. Full strut. In a field. Wide open. Rolled him. When I got to him he ran into the woods and I never saw him again. I was sick for days about not making a quick kill. I vowed to never shoot one in strut again. Whether you mess up meat or not, it's not an ethical shot. I enjoyed the video up to that point though.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
Great video. Thanks for sharing.


It's been proven through history that women's a mystery! Popeye
 
Spurhunter":b00mz2a4 said:
Roost 1":b00mz2a4 said:
Nice video but I wouldn't call shooting one in strut a perfect shot. Just my opinion.
My opinion as well. I lost a bird years ago because I shot him in strut. 42 yards. Full strut. In a field. Wide open. Rolled him. When I got to him he ran into the woods and I never saw him again. I was sick for days about not making a quick kill. I vowed to never shoot one in strut again. Whether you mess up meat or not, it's not an ethical shot. I enjoyed the video up to that point though.
I don't see how it's any less ethical when you have his whole head and neck in full view head-on. I've missed birds with their head straight in the air so I don't think you can blame a strutting bird for getting away from a 42 yard shot. My only concern is the meat which isn't ruined, it's just more shot to pick out. This toms head was freakin tore up!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Roost 1":6irdp06s said:
Nice video but I wouldn't call shooting one in strut a perfect shot.
x2. As usual Cat, great footage. Any hunter out there is rolling the dice when shooting one in strut, and many times, the bird is wounded and never recovered. This video footage should not be shown or promoted to the younger, more inexperienced hunters. My .02
 
d5fce8aeb4697a64242b0ca971547215.jpg


This should show you how much more head and neck is exposed out of strut, and that's why you don't shoot them in strut. But you already know all this. Otherwise you wouldn't have told your buddy to make him come out of strut and pick his head up.
 
Spurhunter":1k6qz8ax said:
d5fce8aeb4697a64242b0ca971547215.jpg


This should show you how much more head and neck is exposed out of strut, and that's why you don't shoot them in strut. But you already know all this. Otherwise you wouldn't have told your buddy to make him come out of strut and pick his head up.
I said that to spare getting shot in the meat. Even with his head tucked up in strut, it's not like shooting a dime, you still have about 10 inches of neck to cover with your pattern...how many pellets you get in a 10 inch circle? It's pretty obviously a dead bird unless you screw up the shot which we all do.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
catman529":s021ftkd said:
....you still have about 10 inches of neck to cover with your pattern...
C'mon Cat, this isn't your girlfriend you are talking to. :rotf: :tu:

In reality, you have an area about as big as your fist to hit when you shoot one in strut, so basically 2" x 3".
 
Seems like y'all had some background or road noise to cover you? Turkeys I've been after lately would been 3 ridges over before I got that shot..


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 
catman529":37xawsus said:
I said that to spare getting shot in the meat. Even with his head tucked up in strut, it's not like shooting a dime, you still have about 10 inches of neck to cover with your pattern...how many pellets you get in a 10 inch circle? It's pretty obviously a dead bird unless you screw up the shot which we all do.

You must be right. Surely generations and generations of seasoned turkey hunters can't know what they are talking about. :roll:
 
Spurhunter":jqx3k0g4 said:
catman529":jqx3k0g4 said:
I said that to spare getting shot in the meat. Even with his head tucked up in strut, it's not like shooting a dime, you still have about 10 inches of neck to cover with your pattern...how many pellets you get in a 10 inch circle? It's pretty obviously a dead bird unless you screw up the shot which we all do.

You must be right. Surely generations and generations of seasoned turkey hunters can't know what they are talking about. :roll:
I'm just going off the amount of blood coming out of various places on that turkeys head and neck. It was nowhere near a marginal shot. I shot one 2 weeks ago with his neck tucked up like that and same result, blood everywhere and stone dead turkey


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
How many will you have to lose to be convinced? Take enough shots like that and it's eventually gonna happen. It's simple do something to make him raise his head. If he is strutting he obviously does not know danger is near, so you got time. Not trying to get on you but every year you make posts about missing birds, this will only add to that number. If nothing else try to learn from others mistakes.
 
Roost 1":26m45kra said:
If nothing else try to learn from others mistakes.

I was talking to my hard headed 18 year old about this last weekend. I told him that I'm not a great turkey hunter. Not even a good turkey hunter. I can't tell you what to do every time, but I can absolutely tell you what NOT to do, because I've made every mistake you can make in the turkey woods. Learn from my mistakes and that's a whole bunch you don't have to make yourself. But, they are young and know everything just like I did when I was that age! :tu:
 
Roost 1":3m10ly80 said:
How many will you have to lose to be convinced? Take enough shots like that and it's eventually gonna happen. It's simple do something to make him raise his head. If he is strutting he obviously does not know danger is near, so you got time. Not trying to get on you but every year you make posts about missing birds, this will only add to that number. If nothing else try to learn from others mistakes.
I never can recall missing a bird because he was strutting. Walking, brush in the way, too far, target panic, but not because one was strutting.

I post a video of a perfectly still bird getting demolished by a good shot and somehow it's unethical...

I guess I'm not the only one having a tough season


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Nice video, Cat.

You can obviously kill a turkey while in strut and even body shots at closer ranges will kill one, but the shot with the highest probability of cleanly killing one is with his neck sticking up.

Keep up the good work with that video camera!




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Your a smart guy cat but apparently missing or ignoring the point being made........never said it can't be done but it's kinda like gut shooting a deer, it's gonna die more times than not. Just hope you find it.
 
catman529":1ssu07ut said:
Roost 1":1ssu07ut said:
How many will you have to lose to be convinced? Take enough shots like that and it's eventually gonna happen. It's simple do something to make him raise his head. If he is strutting he obviously does not know danger is near, so you got time. Not trying to get on you but every year you make posts about missing birds, this will only add to that number. If nothing else try to learn from others mistakes.
I never can recall missing a bird because he was strutting. Walking, brush in the way, too far, target panic, but not because one was strutting.

I post a video of a perfectly still bird getting demolished by a good shot and somehow it's unethical...

I guess I'm not the only one having a tough season


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
i know what they are saying but I would bet just as many turkeys have been wounded and/or missed with their heads stuck straight up. I would not shoot at one strutting if it was turned to the side but if it was facing me and at a reasonable distance I would let him have it with 100% confidence.
 
mathews338":xqmwpj6j said:
...... I would bet just as many turkeys have been wounded and/or missed with their heads stuck straight up.
Of course there have, there have been thousands more shot at with their head up, like 99% of veteran hunters promote. If you shoot the same number with head up as head tucked in strutting (lots of vitals protected), I can promise you more that were shot in strut would run off to die, and never be found by the hunter.
 
Andy S.":tkj4u60m said:
mathews338":tkj4u60m said:
...... I would bet just as many turkeys have been wounded and/or missed with their heads stuck straight up.
Of course there have, there have been thousands more shot at with their head up, like 99% of veteran hunters promote. If you shoot the same number with head up as head tucked in strutting (lots of vitals protected), I can promise you more that were shot in strut would run off to die, and never be found by the hunter.
vitals protected? I thought the whole purpose of shooting them head up is to only shoot the head and neck, not other vitals. In strut you lose a couple inches of the neck but still put your pattern on the majority of the neck and the entire head... Daniel shot this bird lying prone which is I think the most accurate way to shoot, hit where he was aiming and peppered everything from the wattles up to the brain...dead bird...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
catman529":36l35ehz said:
vitals protected?
Correct...vitals as in spinal cord (NECK), wind pipe, jugular vein and other arteries that equate to a quick and humane kill the majority of the time. Sorry for the confusion, should have been more clear. Bottom line, a larger "vitals" target means you miss/cripple less and you recover more birds, and especially true if you shoot numerous turkeys over numerous years.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top