I let one not that old or wide walk 4 times last year during ML, he also had browe tines. But he was a great looking buck. Opening day of rifle he was shot by my hunting buddy on the same property, after I had told him I had let him walk 4 times and would perfer it to stay that way, it seems to do me any good to let them walk, soo I have decided to shoot them all. No not really. AAARRRGGGGHHHH Great looking buck.