Opinions on these bucks...

[Jmed]

Is this the same deer as the one in these pics?






Now help me age this 6 pointer. He got passed during bow season by 2 of us.






And finally, is this a pic of a PHAT buck or what. Looks like he is a butterball. Pic isnt that great.



Had a good card pull today. Glad to see the mullets poachers havent killed em all! Thanks for any opinions!

 

[Shed Hunter]

I'd guess 3.5 on the 6 point. Good bucks!

 

[Jmed]

I believe all of the top 5 pics are of the same buck...do you?

 

[Shed Hunter]

I believe all of the top 5 pics are of the same buck...do you?

Yep.. almost certain it is. It just looks a bit different in the first pic because his head is tilted down.

 

[mathews338]

Same buck in top pics, 3.5 on the 6 imo. Nice bucks

 

[easy45]

Same buck and I think the 6 is 3.5

 

[TheLBLman]

The one (1st few pics) with all the "kicker-sticker" points is very unique. Can't get a good feel for his age from these pics, but believe he's likely 3 1/2. The other buck also appears to be 3 1/2.

 

[Jmed]

I think this is a pic of him last year. I know it aint great. But it was mid December as well....

 

[Big Pop]

Look at the distance between the brow tines in the bottom 2 pix from the top 3 pix. I don't believe they are of same deer.