Curious...

Setterman

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2009
Messages
5,025
Location
Knoxville, TN
I don't hunt turkeys in the fall. I have thought about it, then my childhood lessons from old timers back home rear their head and I put the thought aside. Back home killing hens is taboo, and I was brought up when it came to turkeys, only hunting them in the spring, and only a mature gobbler would be killed.

I could care less if others get jazzed about fall turkey hunting, I am sure it is fun.

I am puzzled a little by the folks who kill gobblers during the fall, it seems to me that those would be given a pass until spring.
 

stik

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 12, 1999
Messages
22,151
Location
lenoir city,tn
they won't let me shoot them in roane or loudon co. :mad:
and we didn't make it to morgan co. during that time.

as far as shooting gobblers in the fall, NO passes from me. i don't hunt them in the spring.
 

Beekeeper

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2009
Messages
12,345
Location
McMinn Co. Tennessee
stik said:
they won't let me shoot them in roane or loudon co. :mad:
and we didn't make it to morgan co. during that time.

as far as shooting gobblers in the fall, NO passes from me. i don't hunt them in the spring.
Can't kill them in McMinn or Rhea either!!
 

TurkeyBurd

Moderator
Joined
Dec 30, 2008
Messages
3,237
Location
Chapel Hill
Agreed about the toms, but thinning the hens doesnt hurt a thing.

Also my 5 from the spring have been long gone from the freezer.

Not a one goes to waste.

But I see your point.(That is hard for me to say to you.) LOL




Setterman said:
I don't hunt turkeys in the fall. I have thought about it, then my childhood lessons from old timers back home rear their head and I put the thought aside. Back home killing hens is taboo, and I was brought up when it came to turkeys, only hunting them in the spring, and only a mature gobbler would be killed.

I could care less if others get jazzed about fall turkey hunting, I am sure it is fun.

I am puzzled a little by the folks who kill gobblers during the fall, it seems to me that those would be given a pass until spring.
 

knightrider

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2010
Messages
10,753
Location
tn
didnt get a chance to go,but i for one think it should be hen only, why protect gobblers in the spring by only allowing one a day be harvested than open them up to flock shooting in the fall?doesnt make since to me,be like having an all you could shoot buck season in the spring.
 

TurkeyBurd

Moderator
Joined
Dec 30, 2008
Messages
3,237
Location
Chapel Hill
Understand your point!

We try not to kill males in the fall, young jakes are confused for hens from time to time though.

Save the Toms for the 'dance of Spring'.


knightrider said:
didnt get a chance to go,but i for one think it should be hen only, why protect gobblers in the spring by only allowing one a day be harvested than open them up to flock shooting in the fall?doesnt make since to me,be like having an all you could shoot buck season in the spring.
 

PickettSFHunter

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2004
Messages
21,821
Location
Jamestown, TN
We have a season in my county but not enough turkeys to justify any conservation minded person shooting hens. And I hate to shoot a gobbler on my place in the Fall, I have few enough gobblers around in the Spring as it is.
 

stik

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 12, 1999
Messages
22,151
Location
lenoir city,tn
smstone22 said:
We have a season in my county but not enough turkeys to justify any conservation minded person shooting hens. And I hate to shoot a gobbler on my place in the Fall, I have few enough gobblers around in the Spring as it is.

not enough? 1 is too many!! :grin:
 

4onaside

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2006
Messages
5,120
Location
Jackson,Tn
As always, to each his own, and that's the way that it should be. I hunted once this fall just to see turkeys and I did! But I doubt if I would have shot a hen, even it was within range(which they weren't). I would like as many male birds as possible on my place in the springtime that are gobbling and come to my call every now and then. And I really could care less if he has a 4" beard or a 13" beard(I killed one of each last spring). lol
 

Lawrence

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2007
Messages
1,924
Location
MT. Juliet Tennessee
I hunted in the fall back in the 80's in MO
and we killed alot of hens but it was nothing to see 300-400
birds in a flock. Now that I live here in Tn I just Spring hunt
Fall hunting is fun but It would be hard for me to shoot a hen because my spots dont have that many birds
 

jb3

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 23, 2009
Messages
6,169
Location
Burns, TN
I use to feel the same way about not shooting hens until recently. Kind of the same feeling I use to have about shooting does. Now that I'm covered up in the birds, some of those hens got to go.
 

PickettSFHunter

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2004
Messages
21,821
Location
Jamestown, TN
Cumberland has 682 square miles of land surface, counting the big city and all that. Reported Spring harvest was 344 birds last year. Thats about .5 birds a square mile harvested and reported. Not that great in my eyes but of course everyone has their own ideas on what is a big population and what isnt. And I dont think a fall hunt affects populations much at all so Im not saying you shouldnt have a hunt or anything like that.

Now compare that with a top county like Dickson, 938 birds harvested and reported last year Spring hunt on 490 square miles.
Thats 1.9 per square mile harvest and reported. Now thats ALOT of birds to me.
 

knightrider

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2010
Messages
10,753
Location
tn
Carlos Viagra said:
Any county that has a fall season should have a huge population of byrds. Cumberland county has plenty of 'em but no fall season yet. I'd guess its going to be added soon with the way they've populated this area, especially Catoosa.
have you looked at harvest numbers for catoosa last year and before, hardly a huge population of birds its a ghost town out there, they killed 400 of off 80000 acres last year
 

paradis1142

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2004
Messages
3,908
Location
crossville tn
knightrider said:
Carlos Viagra said:
Any county that has a fall season should have a huge population of byrds. Cumberland county has plenty of 'em but no fall season yet. I'd guess its going to be added soon with the way they've populated this area, especially Catoosa.
have you looked at harvest numbers for catoosa last year and before, hardly a huge population of birds its a ghost town out there, they killed 400 of off 80000 acres last year
If they killed 400 birds off of Catoosa last year then that place is pretty awesome according to the figures that SMSTONE22 posted up.
 

PickettSFHunter

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2004
Messages
21,821
Location
Jamestown, TN
When I run the figures on Catoosa it shows 91 birds for the Spring hunts in 2010 not 400? 640 acres = 1 square mile. 80,000 acres +- on Catoosa so 125 square miles. Thats a big portion of the county. So 91 birds harvested on 125 square miles is 0.728 per square mile, slightly better than the county average.
 

Latest posts

Top