Have always wondered what this one would score

Got this guy on a camera a few years back. Never saw him during season. Neighbors had camera pictures for the next year, but he was never seen during season or shot. What are your thoughts?

Tough pics for judging but considering he has pretty good kickers off both main beams in the front. I would guess at lease 155

I'd say 160-65. I have a 154" and his G4's are better than mine. And the extra junk adds up too.

155" +


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

Easily into the 165 range

I think he's over 160". No word on if he was killed or not?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Never heard of him getting shot. Was seen the next year on a neighbors camera numerous times but then disappeared. I did take a 174 1/2 this year that had similar features but also a huge drop on the right side. Don't think it was the same deer.

huvrman":22tt2y7h said:

Never heard of him getting shot. Was seen the next year on a neighbors camera numerous times but then disappeared. I did take a 174 1/2 this year that had similar features but also a huge drop on the right side. Don't think it was the same deer.

Click to expand...

Man idk, it could very well be the same deer you killed. They have very similar frames and he developed a flyer.

TN Whitetail Freak":vgiqb000 said:

huvrman":vgiqb000 said:

Never heard of him getting shot. Was seen the next year on a neighbors camera numerous times but then disappeared. I did take a 174 1/2 this year that had similar features but also a huge drop on the right side. Don't think it was the same deer.

Click to expand...

Man idk, it could very well be the same deer you killed. They have very similar frames and he developed a flyer.

Click to expand...

I was thinking the exact same thing...they resemble one another a great deal.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

tree_ghost":1qzdcbn4 said:

TN Whitetail Freak":1qzdcbn4 said:

huvrman":1qzdcbn4 said:

Never heard of him getting shot. Was seen the next year on a neighbors camera numerous times but then disappeared. I did take a 174 1/2 this year that had similar features but also a huge drop on the right side. Don't think it was the same deer.

Click to expand...

Man idk, it could very well be the same deer you killed. They have very similar frames and he developed a flyer.

Click to expand...

I was thinking the exact same thing...they resemble one another a great deal.

EDIT: is it common for you to have deer of this caliber on your properties? I would find it hard to not believe it's the same deer if these are by far the largest two you have seen in your area....

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Click to expand...

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

These 2 are by far the heaviest in mass and points, although this year I saw at least 4 bucks on camera that were larger than any I'd seen in the previous 7 years here. Three of them are in the pics below. The first one was shot this season. The middle one was caught on video again the last week of the season, and no one shot the last one, which I got on camera again in November. None of these have been seen in years past. I figured the 174 I shot might have just been a wanderer like the others. Shot it within 200 yards of where the 2017 pic was taken. Both were also on the bench of a very deep and steep (500 feet or so) hollow where I've seen many deer bed each year. Thick as all get out, and I don't hunt it much because anything shot and trailed into that hollow would have to be cut up and packed out. True billy goat terrain. I suppose it could be the same deer. Maybe all the junk seen in these pictures converted into the big drop tine and cleaner bases.