Harvest Report Data!

Southern Sportsman

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2011
Messages
3,402
Location
West TN
I was actually just going through some of the statewide numbers yesterday. Using the same time range (first 17 days of regular season plus juvenile weekend):

2022 - 20,389 turkeys killed
2021 - 23,598 turkeys killed

We are currently about 13.6% down from last year in total kill numbers. Not terribly surprising given recent trends. But we will probably still kill > 30,000 by year end, so those who measure population health only by kill numbers will insist that there is nothing to worry about.

One thing that concerns me (among several) is the jake kill numbers. Although the total kill numbers have decreased by more than 13%, the jake kill numbers have increased by more than 30% (3012 vs 2308 this time last year).
 

megalomaniac

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2005
Messages
14,849
Location
Mississippi
I was actually just going through some of the statewide numbers yesterday. Using the same time range (first 17 days of regular season plus juvenile weekend):

2022 - 20,389 turkeys killed
2021 - 23,598 turkeys killed

We are currently about 13.6% down from last year in total kill numbers. Not terribly surprising given recent trends. But we will probably still kill > 30,000 by year end, so those who measure population health only by kill numbers will insist that there is nothing to worry about.

One thing that concerns me (among several) is the jake kill numbers. Although the total kill numbers have decreased by more than 13%, the jake kill numbers have increased by more than 30% (3012 vs 2308 this time last year).
Folks are slamming jakes this year for some reason.

If that's because there are so many jakes from a population explosion last year, maybe we'll be ok...

but in prior years with excellent prior year's hatch, Jake harvest has never been over 17% in my counties... This year it's up to 27% IIRC. That's a major problem.

Jakes need to be off limits to everyone except kids for sustainable (my future grandkids) harvest
 

Buzzard Breath

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2006
Messages
6,530
Location
Maury County
Folks are slamming jakes this year for some reason.

If that's because there are so many jakes from a population explosion last year, maybe we'll be ok...

but in prior years with excellent prior year's hatch, Jake harvest has never been over 17% in my counties... This year it's up to 27% IIRC. That's a major problem.

Jakes need to be off limits to everyone except kids for sustainable (my future grandkids) harvest
There's been a 73% increase in the jake harvest on WMA's through the first 3 weekends of the regular season.
 
Last edited:

Boll Weevil

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 26, 2011
Messages
3,762
Location
Hardeman
One thing that concerns me (among several) is the jake kill numbers.
I've referenced the turkey busts in MO and AR in the past but in both cases, the jake harvest exploded. In retrospect, it was a leading indicator of fewer adult toms available to kill and folks simply didn't want to eat a tag. Not sure if that's what's happening here or not but it for sure happened in those 2 states.

Most hunters aren't gonna kill a jake if there's available toms to kill.
 

megalomaniac

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2005
Messages
14,849
Location
Mississippi
I think we will have a statewide opener the 3rd Saturday in April with a limit of 2 turkeys within the next 5 years.

Just hate that it will be 8-10 years later than it should have been.
I'd love this! Except I think we could go back to a 4 bird limit with opening dates after hens have been bred if we outlawed jake killing. I don't need or want to kill 4 birds in TN... but it might pacify the killers who wouldn't want to give up the end of March/ first of April start dates.

Give folks a choice. 1 bird limit if u kill before April 15th. Or 4 bird limit if u wait to kill until after April 15th. Earn an additional tag for every 10 coons removed.
 

paboom

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2008
Messages
225
Location
Tennessee
I've referenced the turkey busts in MO and AR in the past but in both cases, the jake harvest exploded. In retrospect, it was a leading indicator of fewer adult toms available to kill and folks simply didn't want to eat a tag. Not sure if that's what's happening here or not but it for sure happened in those 2 states.

Most hunters aren't gonna kill a jake if there's available toms to kill.
I've talked to several younger folks who say they don't really care if it's a jake or longbeard. A turkey is a turkey to them.

Granted, that's a small sample size based on one man's encounters, but it does seem to match up with today's societal traits of lack of patience and self control.
 

paboom

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2008
Messages
225
Location
Tennessee
I think we will have a statewide opener the 3rd Saturday in April with a limit of 2 turkeys within the next 5 years.

Just hate that it will be 8-10 years later than it should have been.
Obviously a lot can happen between now and then, but in 2024 that would be the 20th of April. That would be a hard sell to the majority of hunters.
 

TnKen

Well-Known Member
2-Step Enabled
Joined
Oct 31, 2008
Messages
1,164
Location
Nash, tn
The Jake harvest is probably due to the number of Jakes this year. I've seen more than I ever have, they are everywhere. I think maybe some are getting shot because hunters have seen the high numbers and aren't worried about knocking one off. Then there is probably some hunters killing one that normally wouldn't be able to get an adult. I just wish the dang jakes would stop harassing the gobblers I'm trying to work.
 

PalsPal

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 1, 2012
Messages
12,089
Location
TN
I've talked to several younger folks who say they don't really care if it's a jake or longbeard. A turkey is a turkey to them.

My 80 yr old dad and 84 yr old friend, who I take every chance I can, feel the same way.

They actually think I'm crazy when I don't shoot a Jake if given the opportunity. The friend says they taste better :D !
 

Top Pin

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2006
Messages
116
Location
Gallatin, Tn
There's been a 73% increase in the jake harvest on WMA's through the first 3 weekends of the regular season.
I'm willing to make a bet that the increase in Jake kills are coming from out of state hunters. It's tough spending a bunch of money to hunt away from home only to go home empty handed. It would be nice for TWRA to show that data!
 

Southern Sportsman

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2011
Messages
3,402
Location
West TN
I'm willing to make a bet that the increase in Jake kills are coming from out of state hunters. It's tough spending a bunch of money to hunt away from home only to go home empty handed. It would be nice for TWRA to show that data!
Non-res license sales were WAY up last year but that didn't increase the jake kill. Maybe I'm being Chicken Little — I hope that's the case — but I'm guessing the increased jake kill is due largely to the lack of available gobblers. Many people only hunt one or two farms. If they go to those farms, hear a few gobblers, and feel like they'll kill one soon, the jakes aren't as tempting. If they go 2-3 times and listen to silent sunrises, then call up a pack of jakes . . . Out-of-staters likely do the same thing in that scenario, but it's not unique to them.

I have a good family friend who is an accomplished deer hunter and a good woodsman, but has never claimed to be a "real" turkey hunter (his word). I say that only to point out that he doesn't keep up with population trends or public sentiment regarding turkeys. Several years back he bought a good deer farm in Carroll County. It had plenty of turkeys, he was there a lot anyway, so he started hunting them and killed a couple every spring. I had lunch with him today. The subject of turkeys came up and he told me "I don't know what it is, but the turkeys up there just don't gobble anymore."

Sadly, I know of a few farms where they just don't gobble anymore.
 

drake799

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 29, 2014
Messages
418
Location
Tn
I'm willing to make a bet that the increase in Jake kills are coming from out of state hunters. It's tough spending a bunch of money to hunt away from home only to go home empty handed. It would be nice for TWRA to show that data!
I seen a younger guy on Facebook from Pennsylvania couple weeks ago he was talking about how his group
Came down and limited out first week of season. 8/9 was jakes come to find out Had to fill them tags….
 

Bgoodman30

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2016
Messages
2,494
The Jake harvest is probably due to the number of Jakes this year. I've seen more than I ever have, they are everywhere. I think maybe some are getting shot because hunters have seen the high numbers and aren't worried about knocking one off. Then there is probably some hunters killing one that normally wouldn't be able to get an adult. I just wish the dang jakes would stop harassing the gobblers I'm trying to work.

I am hoping its only because its a target rich environment and not because hunters are getting desperate...
 

Bgoodman30

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2016
Messages
2,494
I seen a younger guy on Facebook from Pennsylvania couple weeks ago he was talking about how his group
Came down and limited out first week of season. 8/9 was jakes come to find out Had to fill them tags….
Saw that say they do it every year...
 

Levee Jumper

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 11, 2015
Messages
818
I think we will have a statewide opener the 3rd Saturday in April with a limit of 2 turkeys within the next 5 years. I do hate that it will be 8-10 years later than it should have been.
Obviously a lot can happen between now and then, but in 2024 that would be the 20th of April. That would be a hard sell to the

I'd love this! Except I think we could go back to a 4 bird limit with opening dates after hens have been bred if we outlawed jake killing. I don't need or want to kill 4 birds in TN... but it might pacify the killers who wouldn't want to give up the end of March/ first of April start dates.

Give folks a choice. 1 bird limit if u kill before April 15th. Or 4 bird limit if u wait to kill until after April 15th. Earn an additional tag for every 10 coons removed.
You are probably right but protecting jakes would be hard because it's obviously too difficult to tell the difference in a mature tom and a jake or even a hen based on how the current regs are written.
 

hooks

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 14, 2019
Messages
50
Location
Maury County, TN
I think we will have a statewide opener the 3rd Saturday in April with a limit of 2 turkeys within the next 5 years.

Just hate that it will be 8-10 years later than it should have been.
I am all for pushing the season back; even if it is just one week. Think it would help a ton on the NR pressure on public lands.
 

Bone Collector

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 9, 2009
Messages
19,656
Location
Murfreesboro, TN
I was actually just going through some of the statewide numbers yesterday. Using the same time range (first 17 days of regular season plus juvenile weekend):

2022 - 20,389 turkeys killed
2021 - 23,598 turkeys killed

We are currently about 13.6% down from last year in total kill numbers. Not terribly surprising given recent trends. But we will probably still kill > 30,000 by year end, so those who measure population health only by kill numbers will insist that there is nothing to worry about.

One thing that concerns me (among several) is the jake kill numbers. Although the total kill numbers have decreased by more than 13%, the jake kill numbers have increased by more than 30% (3012 vs 2308 this time last year).
Yep they're whacking them where I hunt. called in 7-8 first day of season. Just from what I heard and knowing the gobbles I heard were jake gobbles, I think 3 have been limb lifted, but I haven't seen any in that area since weekend #2, so they may have wiped them all out.
 
Top