What would you do?

Tennessee Deer Sporting & Deer Hunting Community Forum

Help Support TNDeer | Tennessee Deer:

W

wgmac

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2010
Messages
236
City & State/Province
TN,Wilson Co.
This is public land and there are other hunters in the area. Shoot or try and let him go another year or two
firsttry2032.jpg
[/img]
secondtry2047.jpg
[/img]
 
If you'd be happy to kill him, then do just that. I pretty much hunt only public land, and I'd probably kill him.
 
My advice to you is do what makes YOU happy, regardless of what WE think, or anyone else for that matter. Not being a horses rear by any means, just wanting to retain as many hunters in the state as possible, thus I want hunters like yourself to do what makes him or her happy and enjoy the hunt along the way.
 
If you would prefer to kill a larger antlered and/or older buck, the best way for you to do this is to pass up this one, or any one that's smaller/younger than what you prefer.

But if you're happy with this one . . . . . . .
Just saying, just asking, what matters more to you?
 
If you would be happy with him then by all means shoot but if you have to think about it then you prbably will regret it.
 
Well i already know that i will probably take him down if i get the chance. I have been trying to be a little more ethical with my hunting since i have been having good luck the last 5 years. Honestly i am more of a meat hunter that a trophy guy so, if he shows before i get a couple in the freezer then he is going down. But if i he shows up after the freezer is heavy he will probably get a pass. Thanks everyone for your input, just wanted to see what my fellow TNDEER community felt about things. You didn't disapoint!
 
Do what makes you happy. Horns are nice, but make thin soup. I would happily take this deer at close range with a bow or rifle, but would pass him up at 150 yards and a rifle. To me it's about getting close and getting past their senses.

Have fun and enjoy the moment.
 
if your on public land and you let him pass the next hunter he walks under may take him out...so if your a meat hunter id bust him.
 
Andy S. said:
My advice to you is do what makes YOU happy, regardless of what WE think, or anyone else for that matter. Not being a horses rear by any means, just wanting to retain as many hunters in the state as possible, thus I want hunters like yourself to do what makes him or her happy and enjoy the hunt along the way.
Click to expand...
X 2
 
Andy S. said:
My advice to you is do what makes YOU happy, regardless of what WE think, or anyone else for that matter. Not being a horses rear by any means, just wanting to retain as many hunters in the state as possible, thus I want hunters like yourself to do what makes him or her happy and enjoy the hunt along the way.
Click to expand...


Exactly!
 
As others have said, who cares what others think. Do what makes you happy.

But if you are thinking that is a young buck that just needs another year or two to grow a great rack, you would be wrong. That buck has some age on him. He's at least 3 1/2 and might be older. He just "doesn't have it" antler-wise. He would probably get a little bigger in another year, but he isn't going to ever be a large-antlered buck.
 
BSK said:
But if you are thinking that is a young buck that just needs another year or two to grow a great rack, you would be wrong. That buck has some age on him.
Click to expand...
While I agree, there are still other considerations.

There is also the issue of not just what this particular buck may or may not become, but perhaps as much the issue of what you set yourself up for in a totally different buck that might be trailing this one (same day), and/or that survives another year in large part should you pass up this particular one.

What I'm saying is that when bucks are moving, usually the older ones will follow less old ones. And when you pass up, even a 3 1/2-yr-old or older one, then someone else shoots him, that other hunter may simply be shooting that one instead of a different buck, meaning you can improve buck age structure and your odds of taking a buck you prefer more ANYTIME you pass up a particular buck that's a little younger or less than what you value a little more.

Often, the particular buck you pass will be killed by another hunter.
Also, often, a totally different buck ends up surviving because a hunter killed "a" buck and quit hunting.

So even when another hunter kills the one you passed, it may mean 1 buck out of the herd instead of two, since had you killed one, the other hunter may have continued hunting until he also killed one, i.e. 2 bucks removed instead of one.

And if you're willing to think a little farther about this, anytime we pass a buck, we've made a decision that improves buck:doe ratios. The greater the buck:doe ratio, the greater the daytime older buck movement (more competition for females). Passing up a particular buck is often the best way to take a different buck.
 
Thanks for the aging BSK. and to Wes, that is great advise. This deer was always last in my pics following 2 other bucks that were smaller. some of the pics i got were of this one running does and fawns out of the way.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top