Two big bucks. Who's bigger?

[kevlarwiz]

Got a good pic of these two guys this weekend. Which one do you think would score better and what do you think their scores would be?

 

[280longshot]

Super nice bucks whatever they score.

 

[280longshot]

The one on the left looks bigger to me.

 

[Shed Hunter]

Left 146 +- 5
Right 137 +- 5

Left has more tine length. More tine length often results in more score.

 

[hitek7]

I think the one on the left looks bigger due to being closer to the camera. I like both but I think the one on the right may actually be a year older. Don't think there will be much difference in net score between them. Both 140's. Mass measurements will help one on the right.

 

[Shed Hunter]

Got anymore angles?

I bet you are excited for Saturday.

 

[Tennessee Lead]

I tell you which one is bigger the first one to turn broadside

 

[Ladys man]

Idk left has fine length but rights got some long main beams great 10s either way u go

But if I were to shoot one and let other go another yr (wouldn'thappen lol) but left looks older I shoot him first the one on the right looks like he could add more for next yr

 

[Nealmeally]

As far as score, left buck is bigger.. Both are very nice deer!!
Good luck with em!

 

[CALLAHAN]

the buck on the left IMO looks a year older to me just judging by the neck and brisket area, either way these are 2 nice studs and anyone would be proud to have these in their herd!!!

 

[Rockhound]

I'm gonna have to disagree, I'm calling the deer on the right to be older, he's built well, but I think the position of the deer on the left makes his body look older, in reality they are probably both the same age

 

[Food Plot 101]

Both are nice. Deer on the left might score a tad higher but the one on the right has the mass. Whichever one I had a broadside shot at would be the one. Good luck.

 

[MMHunter]

If that doesn't get you excited, I don't know what will.

 

[Realtree]

Giants in my book!!!!

 

[CAW]

Awesome deer! I'd have to say the one on the left will score more simply because he has more tine length. Good luck with them!

 

[Southern Sportsman]

I don't know which one is bigger and I don't know which one would score more, but if they both walked out together and both gave me an equally good shot, I would shoot the one on the right. I can't explain why, but I like him better.

 

[TheLBLman]

Toss a coin.
No significant difference just based on that single pic.

 

[easy45]

I tell you which one is bigger the first one to turn broadside

My thoughts exactly, first one that gave me a shot would be fine

 

[cbhunter]

I do believe the one on the left will score 3-6 inches more than the other one.

 

[kevlarwiz]

Here are a couple more pictures: