Question on 2 buck

Tennessee Deer Sporting & Deer Hunting Community Forum

Help Support TNDeer | Tennessee Deer:

tn droptine

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2008
Messages
1,571
City & State/Province
Lakeland, FL
Do you think we will see a drastic increase on younger bucks being killed late season? I personally think we will, a lot of people that have been letting younger bucks walk earlier in the season will be more tempted to burn a tag later in the year with less chances that they will get a larger buck.
 
Most die hard hunters will not kill them IMO. I think most young bucks will be shot opening gun weekend through thanksgiving weekend
 
spoon":pkahboem said:
Most die hard hunters will not kill them IMO. I think most young bucks will be shot opening gun weekend through thanksgiving weekend
as it has always been. most bucks are killed opening weekend and thanksgiving holidays by "weekend warriors" that are happy with any buck. most that are affected by the limit reduction were already voluntarily passing many bucks.
 
looking at the statistics, late season has always been predominated by bucks killed with fewer points (probably, but not necessarily translates to younger deer... there is very little to no actual age data for bucks killed in late season). I don't see why this season would change from all the prior years.
 
No I think overall buck harvest will b down. Not because of the limit but the way the limit changes hunter mindsets. I have one lease I use mainly for turkeys only. It has 14 members and historically bucks get hammered. As of dark today there has been 1 killed. That is amazing for this property. Heck the oldest member who is in his high 60 and he has never passed a buck. He's been actually talking about issuing a spike. We'll knock me over with a feather. I think the 2 buck limit is working even better than expected. I know it has been surprising.
 
tn droptine":2xrcr3nu said:
Do you think we will see a drastic increase on younger bucks being killed late season? I personally think we will, a lot of people that have been letting younger bucks walk earlier in the season will be more tempted to burn a tag later in the year with less chances that they will get a larger buck.



i certainly don't understand that logic. all i know is that there will be a lot less buck killed at the end of the season and that the age structure of the ones that are will be better
 
tn droptine":dkzykc8x said:
Do you think we will see a drastic increase on younger bucks being killed late season? I personally think we will, a lot of people that have been letting younger bucks walk earlier in the season will be more tempted to burn a tag later in the year with less chances that they will get a larger buck.
Could be. But those managing leases or private property will still let those young bucks walk.
 
For the parts of TN with a later rut, possibly. For the other parts of TN I doubt it. Its hard enough to kill ANY deer late season, let alone a buck. Unless hunting pressure is way down I just dont see any much of a difference.

Im still perplexed on the kill numbers though. Like many has mentioned already, what is the license sales difference if any from previous years.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Interesting question. The true facts about the buck harvest is: A - most deer hunters really don't kill 2 much less 3 a season. B- opening weekend (gun) generally sees a higher number of younger bucks taken simply because its opening weekend and well its a traditional thing and if you don't understand that then there is not enough time to explain it, so the numbers of hunters that are in the woods at a given time is pretty much at its peak. And C - thanksgiving weekend sees a high harvest number simply because most places are closed therefor letting their employees off which in return gives the working hunter more time in the woods resulting in simply the same result as B. Calling someone a weekend warrior simply because the priority to support ones family is a higher priority than hunting is well like downing kids for having a couple days just for them, I'll refrain from any further remarks. The numbers may be down this year, but I will find it hard to believe that the non data to support but politically motivated limit reduction is the cause instead of the mast crop (acorns) being bad and the unusual weather.

It still amazes me that with all the data/information their is and has been available for many years that the belief of simply reducing the number of bucks allowed to be taken is going to produce a road to the promised land.

One more thought, be careful for what you ask for, the commercialization of a natural resource has never ended good.

PS
To some that may read this, don't let the commercialization, ones that measure a bucks worth with a tape measure or politics influence the way you enjoy hunting, Take what you want because IT'S what makes you happy. And remember the ones that "let em walk" are usually not seeing anything anyway. Be proud of being a hunter and that success is not measured in inches.
 
I'm already seeing lots of young bucks killed, last wknd in Crossville saw half a dozen spikes and 4 pts just while eating at Mcdonalds.
 
we have had Giants killed in my area so far this year. I'm sure some are killing yearlings but I haven't seen any at the processor! There have been many deer killed already between 120-160
 
Interesting reply there muddy. But I'll play along a little for kicks. I see your spike and raise you a button buck in the freezer from last weekend.
 
Grill-n-man":1r6sc1s9 said:
Interesting reply there muddy. But I'll play along a little for kicks. I see your spike and raise you a button buck in the freezer from last weekend.

I'm slow. I don't get it. U said most people saying they are passing are not telling the truth I was just saying I was passing and it was the truth. That's all I was saying.
 
Appears a slight misunderstanding has taken pace. Was thinking the passing on the spike was a poke at how the 2 buck limit was working. And my comment was in reference to my favorite game, poker. But the simple fact is where one passes another takes so the road to the promised land aint that short and easy.

Didn't call anyone a liar that aint. But we all have to admit that there sure is a heck of a lot I passed on this and that waiting on the monster crap talk from the kill line at Ft. Campbell to home from those that aint seen nothing but dirt and tree bark. And that comment was directed towards those that might let the check in vultures negatively affect their hunting or make them feel down about any deer that they may have taken.
 
Yes that is irritating. I like the guy with the grunter around his arm telling about everything he's passed and I have known this man for years and I have and I mean never seen him with a dead deer. Those types are annoying. I'm with ya on that. No I didn't pass the spike because of the 2 buck limit. I would pass him if it was. 33. I hope it picks up here tomorrow. Been slow last two days.

In the long run I think the limit will b good but I had a buddy with 250 inches antler with arrows so he is hunting does with his bow. He says he still for the 2 bucks though. Lol
 
I personally will not. I pass younger bucks because that's my choice. I want Compromiise on shooting a buck I passed on earlier in the season just because it's late in the season and I have not shot a buck. If I don't shoot it the first time he's around I want shoot later just to take a buck. I most regularly have plenty of meat by the end of the season so that's not an issue.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Latest posts

Back
Top