- Joined
- Sep 27, 2010
- Messages
- 13,575
not my style to each his own
spitndrum said:Public land birds have heard alot over there lives but if they gobble IDC if he is in the mcdonalds parking lot I'll kill him if I can!
smstone22 said:We did kill a few birds that way but it wasnt my cup of tea.
VolDoug said:smstone22 said:We did kill a few birds that way but it wasnt my cup of tea.
You got something against killing turkeys :D ?
I try to hunt gobbling turkeys, and I will do whatever necessary to find them.
I will take one bird that will gobble to 10 silent ones, but that is just my cup of tea.
hard earned bird right therecruff10 said:I do it all the time.... Mostly on 4wheelers. Somedays I will ride 60 miles to kill a bird....
I have had this same thing happen to me several times over the last ten years. IMO, it would make more sense for the other hunter to stop the truck, get out, and LISTEN for several minutes rather than blowing all the locators known to man. Most hunters would be surprised at how effective LISTENING is compared to blowing a locator call in an attempt to "pull" a gobble out of a turkey. I would rather hunt a turkey that gobbles on his own than one I have to "pull" the gobble out of with a locator. I rarely if ever use locator calls anymore for this exact reason. My .02VolDoug said:I was working a bird one morning fairly close to the road ........
A good while had passed when I heard a vehicle come down the road, stop, and the guy got out and shut the door. He then hit a crow call. I distinctly remember muttering, "please don't gobble, please don't gobble, please don't gobble"! He didn't, and the guy got in the vehicle and drove on. After my staying silent for a good bit, I started calling again softly, which got the old boy fired up again. I killed him a short time later.
Andy S. said:it would makes more sense for the other hunter to stop the truck, get out, and LISTEN for several minutes rather than blowing all the locators known to man.
Setterman said:Laziest crap a person can do, educates birds badly, and generally is low class. Period. No different then riding atv's and doing the same thing.
If the ATV folks only knew how many birds they drive by, and how many hunters they screw up they might quit. Nevermind, those folks don't care about others.
REN said:Setterman said:Laziest crap a person can do, educates birds badly, and generally is low class. Period. No different then riding atv's and doing the same thing.
If the ATV folks only knew how many birds they drive by, and how many hunters they screw up they might quit. Nevermind, those folks don't care about others.
hahah i knew it wouldnt take long!
I was mainly talking about the difference in a turkey that is gobbling on his own or in response to a hen call of some sort, whether it be real or another hunter. I have seen numerous gobblers being worked and gobbling in response to a "hen call" only to be shut down by a hunter repeatedly blowing a locator call. I'm not saying that is always the case, just my experience. Another bigger difference for me over the past 10 years has been my success rate with ones that gobbled "on their own" versus ones I have had to "pull" a gobble out of. Just my preference here, but I will take the former scenario every time as I have had lot better odds killing those birds.VolDoug said:What's the difference if he gobbled to a real owl/crow or to me, as long as he gobbled to something :confused: ?
REN said:Setterman said:Laziest crap a person can do, educates birds badly, and generally is low class. Period. No different then riding atv's and doing the same thing.
If the ATV folks only knew how many birds they drive by, and how many hunters they screw up they might quit. Nevermind, those folks don't care about others.
hahah i knew it wouldnt take long!
REN said:i dont hunt public land or ever get on a 4wheeler during turkey season so i have no dog in this hunt, however i can see both sides and tend to lean to settermans on the public land aspect.
IMO doing my daily 3-6mile walk in a day is part of the hunt i love. Just walking around and enjoying what nature has to offer. again I dont do much on public land so i cant really say why or what people should or shouldnt be doing out there.