Potts strikes again....

Tennessee Deer Sporting & Deer Hunting Community Forum

Help Support TNDeer | Tennessee Deer:

547226_10151932362123623_227464532_n.jpg
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
Kinda funny I was wondering the other day and almost even posted the question if he had scored this year yet or not.
 
woodsman87 said:
Is he one that we consider good, lucky, or both?

IDK...but consider this...their lease consists of 2200 acres truly trophy managed. My buddy and his dad just put in $18000 worth of food plots and they have a farm manager, year around, that oversees all the hunting. Stan shows up and the farm manager has done all the scouting and hung stands. He tells Stan where and when to hunt, all Stan has to do is make the shot!!!!

Good, lucky, or both.....IDK??
 
Roost 1 said:
woodsman87 said:
Is he one that we consider good, lucky, or both?

IDK...but consider this...their lease consists of 2200 acres truly trophy managed. My buddy and his dad just put in $18000 worth of food plots and they have a farm manager, year around, that oversees all the hunting. Stan shows up and the farm manager has done all the scouting and hung stands. He tells Stan where and when to hunt, all Stan has to do is make the shot!!!!

Good, lucky, or both.....IDK??

Maybe we should say he is blessed to have this oppurtunities?
 
EastTNHunter said:
Sounds more like farming than hunting to me.

Absolutely. There is nothing inherently wrong with it, any more than raising beef cattle is wrong. But to me hunting is about learning the land, the animals that live in it, pitting myself against nature, and becoming part of that natural ecosystem. Making the shot--or at least being ready to--is just one very small part of hunting that is significant because it has the power to transform the hunter from a mere observer into a functional part of the natural habitat.

Merely watching, learning, and photography is a wonderful thing, too, but it is not the same as hunting because the watcher has merely observed but not become part of the life cycle. On the other hand, merely walking up and shooting something is not really hunting, either, because the shooter has not become part of the natural habitat, but remained separate and merely plucked something out of it.
 
Roost 1 said:
woodsman87 said:
Is he one that we consider good, lucky, or both?

IDK...but consider this...their lease consists of 2200 acres truly trophy managed. My buddy and his dad just put in $18000 worth of food plots and they have a farm manager, year around, that oversees all the hunting. Stan shows up and the farm manager has done all the scouting and hung stands. He tells Stan where and when to hunt, all Stan has to do is make the shot!!!!

Good, lucky, or both.....IDK??

Well, Dale and another guy put the plots in, don't think his son showed up, 45 acres of corn and beans, not counting the oats.
The Farm overseer doesn't put up stands or scout for deer, Very nice guy and if you were to meet him you'd realize that.
Not saying stands aren't put up, he was there a week hunting this year.

That being said, I wonder if I offered to let 2 TNDeer members hunt on my place how many would say yes and all you had to do was
bring your gear and show up, stands in place? I will say a few,
there's a few guys on here that if they offered that to me I'd go
Just Saying
 
landman said:
Roost 1 said:
woodsman87 said:
Is he one that we consider good, lucky, or both?

IDK...but consider this...their lease consists of 2200 acres truly trophy managed. My buddy and his dad just put in $18000 worth of food plots and they have a farm manager, year around, that oversees all the hunting. Stan shows up and the farm manager has done all the scouting and hung stands. He tells Stan where and when to hunt, all Stan has to do is make the shot!!!!

Good, lucky, or both.....IDK??

Well, Dale and another guy put the plots in, don't think his son showed up, 45 acres of corn and beans, not counting the oats.
The Farm overseer doesn't put up stands or scout for deer, Very nice guy and if you were to meet him you'd realize that.
Not saying stands aren't put up, he was there a week hunting this year.

That being said, I wonder if I offered to let 2 TNDeer members hunt on my place how many would say yes and all you had to do was
bring your gear and show up, stands in place? I will say a few,
there's a few guys on here that if they offered that to me I'd go
Just Saying

Seems like one of us is not getting the same information...
I have always heard, since they have been leasing this property, that the manager and I cant remember his name, has always patterned the deer and put Stan on them. It did take him a little longer this year than ususal....and I could very well be getting bad info but it usually seems to be true.
 
landman said:
Roost 1 said:
woodsman87 said:
Is he one that we consider good, lucky, or both?

IDK...but consider this...their lease consists of 2200 acres truly trophy managed. My buddy and his dad just put in $18000 worth of food plots and they have a farm manager, year around, that oversees all the hunting. Stan shows up and the farm manager has done all the scouting and hung stands. He tells Stan where and when to hunt, all Stan has to do is make the shot!!!!

Good, lucky, or both.....IDK??

Well, Dale and another guy put the plots in, don't think his son showed up, 45 acres of corn and beans, not counting the oats.
The Farm overseer doesn't put up stands or scout for deer, Very nice guy and if you were to meet him you'd realize that.
Not saying stands aren't put up, he was there a week hunting this year.

That being said, I wonder if I offered to let 2 TNDeer members hunt on my place how many would say yes and all you had to do was
bring your gear and show up, stands in place? I will say a few,
there's a few guys on here that if they offered that to me I'd go
Just Saying

Those are very good points, landman. Like I said before, I have no problem with that approach, and I do love venison! I would feel like I am missing out if I never scouted or planned any of my hunts. But I have way of knowing who does or doesn't do their own scouting and planning, and it's not really my business. To each his own, as long as it's legal. For all I know, Potts scouted and picked his own spots and did it all himself--but whether he did or didn't, that's still an amazing deer. Congrats to Potts!
 
who cares. it looks like a nice shooter and he's fortunate to have taken it. i say good on him for making a good kill shot. there's always going to be someone hunting a better property and harvesting a bigger buck than you so just let the dead dog lie....
 
Stan seems to be a good dude. I don't know him.

He has probably paid his dues. Not sure.

I don't care for that kind of hunting. I think it is absoulutely ridiculous to put that much money and effort into killing a deer but then, I don't have that much money so I guess I really can't be too objective.

I am no longer impressed with any deer taken on large, managed, private property, unless I know the hunter and how much he worked for the deer, on the "deers'" terms.

In other words...I am certain that I could gather several friends, pool our financial resources, and build a great, managed property that would likely result in a big buck kill.

I would rather find a mature buck and hunt him right where he is. On HIS turf.

BTW...I am fairly certain that is NOT a 200 inch buck.

Even in velvet.

(not that it isn't a GREAT buck)
 
landman said:
Roost 1 said:
woodsman87 said:
Is he one that we consider good, lucky, or both?

IDK...but consider this...their lease consists of 2200 acres truly trophy managed. My buddy and his dad just put in $18000 worth of food plots and they have a farm manager, year around, that oversees all the hunting. Stan shows up and the farm manager has done all the scouting and hung stands. He tells Stan where and when to hunt, all Stan has to do is make the shot!!!!

Good, lucky, or both.....IDK??

Well, Dale and another guy put the plots in, don't think his son showed up, 45 acres of corn and beans, not counting the oats.
The Farm overseer doesn't put up stands or scout for deer, Very nice guy and if you were to meet him you'd realize that.
Not saying stands aren't put up, he was there a week hunting this year.

That being said, I wonder if I offered to let 2 TNDeer members hunt on my place how many would say yes and all you had to do was
bring your gear and show up, stands in place? I will say a few,
there's a few guys on here that if they offered that to me I'd go
Just Saying
yes sir I will come anytime you offer!!!! lol
 
I like Stan because he seems genuinely excited when he is hunting. I have seen him cry in the stand after making the shot. I wouldn't be ashamed of a deer I took if someone put me in a stand.
 
And BTW landman,
I have been on some of the better leases/lands as a guest.
It was fun to do for a change. Relaxing, different, interesting, EASY.

I took very little sense of satisfaction walking away with a dead deer from those properties. I did not "earn" them.
 
102 said:
And BTW landman,
I have been on some of the better leases/lands as a guest.
It was fun to do for a change. Relaxing, different, interesting, EASY.

I took very little sense of satisfaction walking away with a dead deer from those properties. I did not "earn" them.

102
If you get a new place to hunt in mid season, and send half a day scouting it after the landowner tells you were he's been seeing a buck, a big one he thinks but he's not a hunter. After
3-4 hours looking around you hang a stand in the area were the landowner says even other places look just as good and kill a buck YOUR happy with the next morning did you earn it?

As far as those other bucks on the leases, why did you even shoot
one? You weren't happy with them? Or was it just to punch a tag?
Or kill a buck in front of the guys? Why even go hunting on those kind of places? At that point in my life, I think it be just better to be out in the woods thanking God for letting me be there, why load the gun at all? Hunting is what one makes it,
its personal, so its your choice my all means
 

Latest posts

Back
Top