Mature 7 point

Tennessee Deer Sporting & Deer Hunting Community Forum

Help Support TNDeer | Tennessee Deer:

ZachMarkus

Well-Known Member
Gold Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2011
Messages
4,348
City & State/Province
Middle TN
Killed him Sunday afternoon just cruising through the timber. I was hunting a different buck, I had no idea this one was around. The rack size wasn't really what I was looking for but I will burn a tag on a mature deer any time I get a chance!

d7cf85ccee7377d2282e979b12273cd2.jpg
 
megalomaniac":2dg0l28a said:
good for you! A deer with that rack at 4.5+ needed to go. did you slit his throat? :)

Lol no. I shot him through both shoulders and dropped him and he was about to run to the bottom of the biggest holler on the farm so I shot him in the neck.
 
docpoco":3c5xn2j7 said:
megalomaniac":3c5xn2j7 said:
good for you! A deer with that rack at 4.5+ needed to go. did you slit his throat? :)

Huge studies have been done that show culling has no effect on herd genetics, even after 5+ years.

Some of these Studies have been on places with controlled herds.

The idea that there is a need to remove a deer from the herd in the wild because of genetics is outdated and ineffective.


I think he meant that the buck needed to go because that's as big of a rack as he was ever going to grow. Not that he needed to be taken out to help with herd genetics.
 
What a knarly old buck! Man there ain't nothing better than that! Congrats on a great buck buddy!!!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
docpoco":2wpiebkb said:
megalomaniac":2wpiebkb said:
good for you! A deer with that rack at 4.5+ needed to go. did you slit his throat? :)

Huge studies have been done that show culling has no effect on herd genetics, even after 5+ years.

Some of these Studies have been on places with controlled herds.

The idea that there is a need to remove a deer from the herd in the wild because of genetics is outdated and ineffective.

We (or typically I let my daughter or kids eventhough I am not against shooting any mature deer) shoot the older deer with smaller racks not to control our herd genetics but most of these bucks tend to be aggressive on our farm. Plus, big ol mature deer consume alot of food and why do I want inferior rack bucks eating food that bucks that have more potential could be eating? I understand shooting 1 or 2 a year is not going to help a whole lot but it sure is not going to hurt a whole lot. Everyone is entitled to an OPINION.

Anyway, congrats on a mature buck!
 

Latest posts

Back
Top