Help me pick one

[TX300mag]

Not a good angle

Same buck? If so, I think he's mature.

Best quality overall. 3.5?

Better angle

 

[easy45]

I would have to take that bottom ine

 

[Nealmeally]

Bottom buck gets killed on my places. And I think he's 4.5+..

 

[Inkstainz]

Bottom is the best but I'd take any of them

 

[catman529]

that second buck is older than 3.5 for sure. and I'd rather kill that one too. good luck

 

[TX300mag]

OK, thanks. I'm pretty confident now that the top two pics are the same buck. I've got another pretty decent buck with several pics if I can find them, but I think he may be a good 2.5.

 

[Phil1979]

Bottom is the best but I'd take any of them

X2

 

[megalomaniac]

top buck in mature (4.5 or older)
second buck is only 3.5, IMO

 

[harley 2008]

Bottom buck

 

[spitndrum]

top buck and 2nd pic are definatly the same buck would shoot the bottom buck 1st if it were me

 

[Florida Cracker 971]

If they walked out together & I had the chance to choose I would take the the last buck, I like his mass & chocolate antlers. But all are fine animals.

 

[rrhoghead]

bottom

 

[rem270]

First one would definately get a pass.

2nd one would be dead if it came in range.

 

[landman]

are these in Texas?

doesn't really matter but I'd shoot the bottom one, I really don't think he's over 3.5 yr

No sway back
long legs
slim neck from chest to head
see how no belly either, tight up in front of the hams
no loose skin between the front legs

3.5yr IMO

 

[TX300mag]

Thanks landman. This is a place here in TX I recently got permission to hunt.

Not sure when I'll hunt it since I'm already gonna be in TN and OH until almost mid-December. Luckily rifle starts Nov 2 here, so that may be it until then.

Unless you're in a certain level of CO-op in the management program, you're only allowed one buck 13" or better.

 

[TX300mag]

Bottom buck came within 20' of my BIL, but behind him and didn't offer a shot. I sure hope he nails him!

 

[Adam Jackson]

Bottom buck for sure

 

[Boone 58]

like the bottom, but not one of them would get a pass frm me I think!

 

[SelphLogging]

I think both are 4.5. But the bottom is mature almost for sure

 

[stryker]

Bottom buck is awesome

 

[trukeyhunter]

Bottom buck is the best but all good bucks.

 

[TX300mag]

Brother in law killed the bottom buck!