help me decide

Tennessee Deer Sporting & Deer Hunting Community Forum

Help Support TNDeer | Tennessee Deer:

PickettSFHunter

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2004
Messages
23,698
City & State/Province
Jamestown, TN
Heres the one situation/option... I have some "play" money Ive made off some timber. I have sold 20 acres of my 55 acre mature park like timber in order to get some cover in there. Didnt want to sell more due to low timber prices. I have zero food plots, and zero fruit trees on this place. However, even without cover, I see all kinds of deer here, 80 something this year, 19 in one day. Pretty good for Unit B. However, its rare that a mature buck feels like venturing out in the daylight during any firearms season with no cover, so I had to get the cover in there by cutting. I hunt this property alot, as its enjoyable to see deer all the time, I also let friends and my Dad hunt here with me. Together we have taken 11 deer in 2 seasons. 2 good bucks and 9 does. You could say we have gotten alot of use out of it. Aerial photo below, timber is being cut along the road and behind the houses in the yellow outlined areas. Large cleared areas to the North and East are now thick planted pines.
millcreekboundary.jpg


Now the other situation/option, my 85 acres in the mountainous section of Fentress County. I have 4 food plots near 5 acres and over 100 apple trees and 20 some odd pears and numerous other various mast trees planted. Plenty of food for what few deer are there. I only hunt this property in gun, maybe 10 times a year, just myself, no one else. I have killed one deer on this place in 5 seasons, I dont shoot does, only mature bucks there. Ill average seeing 15 deer a season there. So you could say Ive not gotten much use out of it I guess but it is my favorite place, its home and has some giants around. What Im missing here is one single large enough field to put some summer crop in, like forage soybeans.

So on to my decision I need to make.... I have this play money, and I could do both projects but Im getting married so Im just going to use a small percentage for one project and put the rest back. So do you...

A. Put 2 or 3 1 acre or so plots/orchards in on the 55 acres given that situation OR

B. Expand a 1.2 acre plot on the 85 acre, turning it into 4 acre field where I could grow corn/soybeans/sunflower/milo etc.

Thats what Im going back and forth in my head about, hope I made sense with it all. Any input and reasons why would greatly appreciated. I really enjoy food plots and growing fruit trees, even though they arent necessarily needed.
 
Congrats on getting married.

I'd do B. And plant forage beans in the summer. Wheat, oats, rye, and clover in winter. With one acre left in Durana. This should give you a year around food source.
 
B. You can then add some annual fall plantings as needed around the edges as well as add some apple or pear trees.
 
Congrats man! I'm only 4 months in but it has been great.

I think I would do B...

From your posts it seems like you are likely to cut/sell the 55 at some point. I'd put money into the property you feel like keeping and expanding on in the future.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
Or option C. put all that "play money" into the bank to buy you some more land in the future to help pay for that new "investment" of yours :)
 
Another thought, do not cut the timber all the way to the road, leave a slight buffer.

Guess I would have to go with A. Sounds like more deer than may need more food to have the growth potential. Plus it sounds like you would get more for your money since it is hunted more.

The summer plot on "B" may help grow a little bigger deer but they may "range shift" after grown. It may help hold a few more does around.
 
Oh Im always in the land buying market. I keep spare change on hand for that, dont count that as play money. This doesnt change that a bit, always looking for the next guy that goes under to get a deal from lol Thanks for the input.
 
Option B. Our corn plot draws in more deer/turkeys than anything else. I recommend a good corn/bean planter though. Corn seed is too expensive anymore to not get it in the ground correctly. I wouldnt go much less than 5 acres like TX300 said.
 
Congrats on the marriage.
I personally like the multiple food plot option over the one only.
just my opinion....A. :cool:
 

Latest posts

Back
Top