Have owned both the H&R and NE and both are as good as it gets,accuracy wise.Most people who cannt group with them either havent found the right load,have developed a flinch or the mounts,rings or scope are cheap.Mounted with the right mounts and rings is essential.No place here for cheap scopes.
At this time the H&R and a 1187 Remington are in my safe.
The H&R loves Winchester Hi Impact 2 3/4 load at 1250 fps.
Trouble is they dont make em any more.
The 1187 shoots them well also.My stock of this is almost gone so last year i started looking for another load for the 1187.
Have never been a fan of 3in loads but the Remington Aero Tip,the green one,will shoot under 2 in at 100 yards and about 4in at 150.Probably do better with younger eyes also. :grin:
I have an old 6 power Weaver on my H&R.Dont laugh,the old Weavers are very reliable.On my 1187 a Kahles 3X9 is mounted.Both have taken 100s of slug rounds and hold up nicely.
The H&R actually shoots a little better than the 1187.
Good luck with your decision.