Hangnail said:
If there was a problem with fishing for trout during their spawning period, don't ya think someone with TWRA would have tried to have a closed season for them?
Well, like I said, TWRA
does have a closed season on spawning browns, at least on the upper part of the South Holston.
Someone mentioned trout being "stocked every year," but the browns on the SoHo are naturally reproducing, not stocked.
I guess if you find a brown trout spawning outside of the areas closed by TWRA, you can go after that fish, though you're yanking a fish off the bed that doesn't have quite the same level of spawning success as the crappie and bass mentioned above.
There's somewhat of a "cultural difference" between trout fishermen and bass fishermen when it comes to fishing to spawning fish. A lot of hardcore bass guys are just fine with it (though I have to wonder about how tournament guys yanking all the bass off the beds affects the spawn - ever hear anyone complain that the bass fishing isn't what it used to be 25 years ago?).
Hardcore trout fishermen, on the other hand, tend to look down on it. Maybe part of it is that trout are a lot more vulnerable than bass when they spawn, since they tend to do it in knee-deep narrow riffles where you can practically walk right up to them and drop a hook on their noses. I don't know.
As far as I'm concerned, I just don't see a lot of sport in a bunch of people standing in a circle around a big spawning brown, casting to it over and over until one person gets it to eat (or, just as likely, snags its back). It's like shooting fish in a barrel. You think a fish that size would ever let you get that close in two-foot deep water any other time of year? No way, Jose. The spawn lets people cast at those fish all day like they're big trophy anglers, when in all honesty a lot of them don't have the skills to get within fifty yards of a 20-inch fish when it's not trying to tend eggs.
Is it legal? Most places outside of the SoHo, yeah. So if it blows your skirt up, I guess you can have at it.
Of course, "hunting" an elk on a fenced-in game farm in a 40 acre yard is LEGAL, so have at it if that's your definition of fun. Just don't expect me to think you're a big man when you shoot one.
Just my opinion.
bd