Caliper recommendation?

Tennessee Deer Sporting & Deer Hunting Community Forum

Help Support TNDeer | Tennessee Deer:

Hardwoodmaterials

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 14, 2011
Messages
2,789
City & State/Province
Hohenwald,Tn
I was using my digital caliper today and noticed it was acting a little odd so I changed the battery. I can measure the same thing and get a different measurement every time now and the display has started glitching. I think I'm just going to pick up a good dial set but I don't know much about them. Anyone recommend a good reliable set that won't break the bank?
 
I do not care for the digital calipers. I am using a plain old Lyman dial caliper. It isn't fancy and it doesn't sit well in my hands but it is accurate.

It gets a lot of use. I like every round to be the same length. Not + or - a few thousandths. The same length. This is why I have my 'shoot-em-up' box for every caliber.

I am looking for a backup caliper so I am going to pay attention to this thread.
 
Dial calipers from Harbor Freight aren't bad for around the house use. I have a old set of Browne & Sharpe that I use for reloading. The new B&S calipers aren't as good as the older ones for closer work. As far as that goes none of the new measuring tools are as smooth as the older ones. You can find some good deals on a good set of calipers at some pawn shops.
 
I like Starrett dial calipers ,,we use them at work and are kinda rough on them and they hold up pretty good considering the crap we put them through,,I figure a cheap model Sterrett would last a hobby type reloader a lifetime,,also at work they say no digital caliper is reliable enough to stake our companys reputation on and are not allowed to use on the floor for anything,,

I have a cheap pair of Mitutoyo`s to measure groups and non critical stuff but when I need to measure something I want an accurate reading on at my reloading bench I use my Starrett mics that go to ten thousandths,,

Browne and Sharpe stuff is good also but I would not recommend any of the digital calipers that cost less than 80-90$$ ,,

get the Starretts 6 inch dial calipers in the 100-125$ range and you will be set for life to just reload ammo with,,
 
Buy quality once, as in Starrett or B&S, and you won't have to buy again most likely. I use these tools daily, and a quality instrument lasts, while lesser(harbor freight for ex) will likely give out way before the higher quality items will.
 
Starrett dials will last you a lifetime if taken care of properly. Brown&Sharpe also a good pick. Central tools also have well made set of dial calipers. Digitals don't have good longevity.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
I just priced some of these quality calipers and there is a big price difference between 6", 8" and 12" models. What size do you guys have and furthermore, based on all of your years of reloading and such, what size is really needed 95% of the time?
 
I have been looking at some of the ones mentioned here and all the new Starrett models I have found around $80-$100 seem to be made in China with plastic internals. I figured for that price they would be have metal internals and made anywhere but China. Am I looking at the right ones? All the B&S and Mitutoyo I have found so far are out of my price range for a set. Anyone know anything about the Fowler brand calipers? I'm going to have to order a set since I can't find any on a store shelf any where around here.
 
I have a Brother-in-Law who was an Airframe and Powerplant licensed mechanic and could taxi 4-engine jets (no passengers). He has tools that cost a weeks pay each. He has owned and used them since the mid-1970's. Some he inherited from his Father.

Good tools last a long time and are worth the investment.
 
Mitutoyo digital are what most people use at my work, we make medical parts that go into people's bodies. They also calibrate them once a year to ensure they are still reading right. Folwer dial is pretty good for the price but I have seen fowlers break, haven't seen many mitutoyo break.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G920A using Tapatalk
 
question on the Mitutoyo calipers. The reason for them is because they can be connected on line? So that medical devices are tracked through the manufacturing process? There an auto-feedback like if a part is out-of-spec an alarm goes off???
 
rstodd":1kg8230b said:
Mitutoyo digital are what most people use at my work, we make medical parts that go into people's bodies. They also calibrate them once a year to ensure they are still reading right. Folwer dial is pretty good for the price but I have seen fowlers break, haven't seen many mitutoyo break.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G920A using Tapatalk

I've had bad bad luck with anything digital from mitutuyo

I seen around 50 micrometerss crap out in less than a year
 
rstodd":2zop8tn4 said:
Mitutoyo digital are what most people use at my work, we make medical parts that go into people's bodies. They also calibrate them once a year to ensure they are still reading right. Folwer dial is pretty good for the price but I have seen fowlers break, haven't seen many mitutoyo break.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G920A using Tapatalk

Do you work for emhart (stanley)
 
DaveB":27l7zzvb said:
question on the Mitutoyo calipers. The reason for them is because they can be connected on line? So that medical devices are tracked through the manufacturing process? There an auto-feedback like if a part is out-of-spec an alarm goes off???
No our company doesn't do that. One reason I like them is you can switch between standard and metric and check the depth of a hole using a gage pin pretty quick.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G920A using Tapatalk
 
I'm just measuring during reloading. I don't need them for a job and they won't be anywhere but in the case on the reloading table when I'm not using them. I just want a set that is repeatable and fairly accurate. Is it just me or do most all of them look like the same 3-4 sets with different brand names stuck on them?
 
For reloading, any decent stainless steel 6" caliper is fine. Absolute accuracy isn't really as important as repeatability. The main dimension you would be measuring with this instrument is going to be overall cartridge length. Unless you are using a tipped bullet, the variation in the bullet's deformed lead nose is going to overshadow the variability in the tool. To really be set up for measuring case head diameter you'll also need a 0-1" micrometer. Again, absolute accuracy is not as important as repeatability. As a reloader we aren't measuring a case to fit in any gun, but for our gun only so if your tools aren't calibrated properly, it's not that big a deal as long as you only have the one tool. The plastic 6" calipers sold for reloaders may work fine if you are really careful with them, but I've always been hesitant to get one because it would be really easy to make a nick or gouge on the face of the jaws and then they are messed up for good. I got some mid priced stainless steel calipers years ago and also a Craftsmen caliper, both of which have been dependable. I don't recall the brand of the 0-1" micrometer that I use for reloading but it was given to me by a machinist. I also have a 0-1" Craftsman and a cheapo Chinese model. They all work for reloading purposes. Sure, I'd love to have a Starret set but don't really see the need for an individual to spend that much to just to reload unless you have the money simply want to.

In the above I was assuming the caliper would be a dial type. I've been to too many companies where the Quality department would not allow the use of digital calipers to accept product. Also, the only advantage I can see with digital compared to a dial type caliper is the ease of reading the measurement. Once you get used to a dial type, they really aren't hard to read at all.
 
Hunter 257W":e2l2ztyt said:
For reloading, any decent stainless steel 6" caliper is fine. Absolute accuracy isn't really as important as repeatability. The main dimension you would be measuring with this instrument is going to be overall cartridge length. Unless you are using a tipped bullet, the variation in the bullet's deformed lead nose is going to overshadow the variability in the tool. To really be set up for measuring case head diameter you'll also need a 0-1" micrometer. Again, absolute accuracy is not as important as repeatability. As a reloader we aren't measuring a case to fit in any gun, but for our gun only so if your tools aren't calibrated properly, it's not that big a deal as long as you only have the one tool. The plastic 6" calipers sold for reloaders may work fine if you are really careful with them, but I've always been hesitant to get one because it would be really easy to make a nick or gouge on the face of the jaws and then they are messed up for good. I got some mid priced stainless steel calipers years ago and also a Craftsmen caliper, both of which have been dependable. I don't recall the brand of the 0-1" micrometer that I use for reloading but it was given to me by a machinist. I also have a 0-1" Craftsman and a cheapo Chinese model. They all work for reloading purposes. Sure, I'd love to have a Starret set but don't really see the need for an individual to spend that much to just to reload unless you have the money simply want to.

In the above I was assuming the caliper would be a dial type. I've been to too many companies where the Quality department would not allow the use of digital calipers to accept product. Also, the only advantage I can see with digital compared to a dial type caliper is the ease of reading the measurement. Once you get used to a dial type, they really aren't hard to read at all.

This

I have a very old inherited starrett but I use a Lyman because it is what I started with. I check it every couple months and it has never been off. They are inexpensive, got mine for $20 on sale a few years ago.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top