I have no idea exactly how many deer I have killed-well over 300 and probably closer to 400-but by far, the majority have been with a bow. For about 20 years, I hunted very little with anything else. Now I am back to shooting whatever I feel like when it is legal.
I will admit, I do get greater satisfaction from bow kills and then either mzl or rifle. But the real satisfaction comes in choosing the right stand site and hunting it correctly. If I do that, usually the actual shot is anticlimatic.
For me, the greatest thrill in deer hunting is to walk into a piece of timber I have never seen before and hang a stand in the right place, the first time and make the kill the first time I hunt it.
With elk, calling one into shooting range was the thrill. With mulies it was the stalk and with antelope, it was beating the heat and rattlers.