Buck in first pic looks like the quintessential 4.5yr old to me and I agree 130's.
However, the buck in the front second pic is the one I'd be excited about. He's 5+ IMO and although wouldn't score as high he's still a tank and I like hunting old bucks. I love that sagging jowl and weird flier point. I think the deer behind him is the same 10pt in first pic.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
However, the buck in the front second pic is the one I'd be excited about. He's 5+ IMO and although wouldn't score as high he's still a tank and I like hunting old bucks.
I don't think there's enough view angles to accurately score these antlers.
But buck in top pic, I would categorize him as high 120's for my purposes,
even though he "might" score into the low 130's.
With both age & score, I want to think in terms of the minimums that can be stated with high conviction.