Age and score!!!!

[cbrock84]

What do y'all think on age an score on both bucks. Both same property city deer.

 

[megalomaniac]

I think you actually have 3 different bucks!

First 2 pics are of a 4.5 or older buck scoring low 140s

3rd pic of the 10pt is a 3.5yo scoring high 130s

4th pic is a 5.5yo 10 pt scoring mid 140s

 

[cbhunter]

Dates are pertinent info. I agree the last two pics could be of diff deer but I'm leaning more towards same buck and the pics being a couple months apart

 

[Tom Collins]

Dates are pertinent info. I agree the last two pics could be of diff deer but I'm leaning more towards same buck and the pics being a couple months apart

That's my thought too. November and December pics imo.

 

[backyardtndeer]

Score, good enough. Age 4.5 or better.

 

[cbrock84]

There November an December pics. Sorry had to zoom camera in to take better pics. Its same 10 point

 

[Snake]

I think you actually have 3 different bucks!

First 2 pics are of a 4.5 or older buck scoring low 140s

3rd pic of the 10pt is a 3.5yo scoring high 130s

4th pic is a 5.5yo 10 pt scoring mid 140s

Maybe wrong but I'm inclined to think like mega , thinking #3 and #4 different bucks . #1 & #2 going to say high 130's to low 140's probably 4.5 , #3 low140 's 5.5 , # 4 low140 's 5.5 . If you say there the same buck I have to believe you but looking at the pics they sure look different .

 

[Shed Hunter]

Deer 3&4 are the same deer. Picture three is taken accurately and picture four is screen tilted.

For validation of my point observe the knot on his antler near the left G3

 

[megalomaniac]

Deer 3&4 are the same deer. Picture three is taken accurately and picture four is screen tilted.

For validation of my point observe the knot on his antler near the left G3

Good eye, you are right!

On that case, I think the 10pt is 3.5 and high 130s

 

[JCDEERMAN]

Deer 3&4 are the same deer. Picture three is taken accurately and picture four is screen tilted.

For validation of my point observe the knot on his antler near the left G3

Those were my thoughts as well

 

[Shed Hunter]

Good eye, you are right!

On that case, I think the 10pt is 3.5 and high 130s

Very nice potential

 

[Deer444]

What do y'all think on age an score on both bucks. Both same property city deer.

Can't age a deer by horns but a nice deer i would say over 3.5