BSK and LBLman,
Interesting observations. So I have a question about deer's movement and thinking, and I hope I can word it properly. Are deer able to conceptually understand a "the grass is greener over there" mentality or are they driven more by instinct/habit/etc? For example, will a buck comprehend that there are few does in his home range and go looking for a place with more does or is he going to stay within his range and simply deal with what is there?
Complicated question to answer. First, it is believed Humans are the only animal on the planet with an imagination. It is believed that to have an imagination requires language. In that, you must be able to think in words to be able to imagine different outcomes (to reason). This is why I don't believe deer to have the ability to reason their way through a problem. They simply react instinctively, and as long as that reaction "works," they will keep doing that same thing to the same stimuli. Until it doesn't work. Then they will try something else. But they are not "reasoning" their way through the problem. In essence, to go through an "if-then" scenario in their heads requires an imagination to conceptualize if I do this, this or this
might happen.
That said, GPS collar data has shown deer doing some really bizarre things. One of the most common bizarre behaviors is termed the "walkabout." It has been noted in many GPS collar studies that virtually all bucks 2 1/2 or older, at some point during the rut, go on "walkabout." They simply take off and walk in virtually a straight line for several miles. They then spend 48 hours in that new location, after which they return along the same route back to their normal range. What are they doing at that new location for 48 hours? Are they breeding a doe? If so, how did they know she was there, miles away? Again, no one really knows why bucks do this or why they choose the direction they go.
Another odd behavior is the rut range shift. Some bucks up and leave their normal range and shift to a new range miles away, staying only for about the peak 6 weeks of the rut. Afterwards, they return to their original range. How did they know to go to this other range for the rut, and why? To make matters even more strange, some of these rut range-shifting bucks never go back to the same rut range twice. They move to a separate and different rut range every year. Why? Why choose the location they go to?