I still say they should play the SEC championship for 1st and 2nd in the country and let everyone else play for third place
-
Help Support TNDeer:
Georgia vs FSU
- Thread starter Bamamonts
- Start date
This game showed 100% the committee got it wrong. GA should be in the final 4
So then who do they leave out? Washington?
BamaProud
Well-Known Member
Every team has the potential for opt outs or transfers.
Roster management is 100% on the coaching staff.
You think Washington beats GA head to head?
Highly doubtful, I agree Georgia is a top 4 team. IMO Washington is the weakest of the current top 4.
deerhunter10
Well-Known Member
I think Washington beats Texas.
Georgia should have been in top 4 ,like to see Alabama and Texas play again
If I had to guess I'd say they will be in the championship game.
History is filled with teams that won the Championship that weren't the best team. Whether it's 2 or 4 or 12 or 64 teams that make the playoffs, the best team doesn't always win. The committee doesn't have an easy job and I understand that, but even THEY know they cannot pick the best teams for the playoffs. Sports that have a multi-game series like the NBA and MLB have a far greater chance of THE best team winning the championship. It just doesn't work that way in football because of the nature of the sport.
I'll be shocked if they do, Texas is the more complete team but we will see. That pac 12 defense has never impressed me.
I think Michigan is the weakest team, and Alabama will prove that in spades. The only thing about Washington that is weak is their defense, but I think their defense is better than Michigans offense.
PillsburyDoughboy
Well-Known Member
FSU has starters out and loses ? Sounds familiar, Looks like the committee got it right then!
buckaroo
Well-Known Member
They would have all played if they were in playoffs I'm sure
Outcome woulda been the same
Not necessarily with the way that the current selection is setup… I think that this season would have potentially had 4, but the guaranteed conference champions and G5 appointments make it to where it's not just the top 12 teams
After bowl games, depending on how lsu does, the sec could have 5 teams finish top 10. Bama, Georgia, mizzou, ole miss are already there. LSU sitting at 13 with several teams above them getting embarrassed
I'm sorry, I misread your post to allude to the top 12 in reference to next year's 12 team playoff. You are likely correct
ImThere
Well-Known Member
They should have stopped the sec championship years ago. Then what would the excuse be?
