I feel lucky that I live close enough to Reelfoot I can be on the water fishing in about 15 minutes. If I want to have some fish I just run down and catch a few. I usually fillet 4 or 5 fish. There's only 2 of us eating it.
If we take home crappie, we take just what we will eat that night. I rather have them fresh. I dont like fish that have been frozen. I, too, am concerned about over harvesting at Reelfoot. To me the numbers have declined.
Shorter season would put less pressure and stress on the deer. Archery starts the end of September. Gun season could end the middle of December. That is a lot of opportunities to hunt even if only 1 day per week.