I have been reading different threads that seem to show that several people posting on this site want either a 1 or 2 buck limit. My question is “Why”?

Some questions about the intent of this idea should be answered before such a reduction in bag limit is even considered.

1. In areas with a high population of deer, how many does are not bred each year? This can be determined by looking at the does in the spring and summer and counting the ones that have fawns and those that do not. Take into consideration the predator population and that a certain percentage will have still births and others will be killed by vehicles in the area and this will give you a good idea of the percent of does bred in this area.

2. In areas with low populations of deer, how can lowering the limit on bucks increase the total herd? If the bag limit on does is cut or eliminated the herd will grow quicker regardless of the buck limit.

3. If all you are wanting is to be able to take a “Trophy”, they are here now! How many pictures of mature deer have been posted on this site since the last day of the season? These deer have been here all season and were not killed. Many other mature deer were taken this year and many more will be taken next year even without a reduction in the bag limit.

I know a lot of people will not like this post but answer these questions honestly and if you can convince me and others that there is a valid biological reason that will improve the health of the total herd we may get on your side.

Remember that a Bucks primary purpose is to breed does, not to become a decoration in someone’s home.

Is that Jr's fault or yours?

Its all about rack size,they will try to say herd health,but when it comes down to it,they just want bigger antlers.